It’s good when you consider vanilla ice cream. We’re not that discriminating when it comes to vanilla ice cream. If we want better we go to the local ice cream shop for home made.

My husband loves vanilla ice cream and this large pail contains more than the gallon pails at the local grocery store which runs out of ice cream often. I can always count on it being available at Sam's Club and my husband is happy.

Why does Sam’s Club make to types of ice cream ? Members Mark Supreme ice cream is delicious, the Members Mark ice cream in the pail is bland. I was very disappointed that they didn’t offer the Supreme ice cream online for delivery. It’s terrible.

Decent budget ice cream, good for feeding a crowd of kids when you’re on a budget. However, you’ll know immediately that this isn’t the smooth high cream content (and more expensive) brand.

We purchase this ice cream every week because we devour it. Delicious by itself, over pie, a banana split, in a milk shake or root beer float...just a few ways we use it.

Very large amount of cheaply made ice milk with an insipid taste. And the lid sticks to the tub. You must pry it off a bit and then bend it back nearly double to remove it.

This ice cream is really good and creamy. We always get the vanilla, then add our own toppings or make floats. It is always in stock. AND the grandkids love this ice cream.

It was not what I expected from a Sams Members Marks product. It has too much corn syrup and you could taste it overwhelmingly. Also lack that creaminess of ice cream. I should have returned it. That was a waste of money I’ll never buy it again.

I'm not a great fan of plain vanilla ice cream; however, add Hershey syrup and a few pecans and you have a perfect Sunday and you can also add whipped cream on top. UUM!

You definitely get a lot of bang for your buck with this ice cream! There is a TON of ice cream in this container. Even with a big family, this has lasted us a while!