It’s good when you consider vanilla ice cream. We’re not that discriminating when it comes to vanilla ice cream. If we want better we go to the local ice cream shop for home made.

I was surprised by the flavor of this ice cream. It's also a 5 quart pail which is almost impossible to find anymore. Price is comparative to a 4 quart pail at local grocery stores!

It was not what I expected from a Sams Members Marks product. It has too much corn syrup and you could taste it overwhelmingly. Also lack that creaminess of ice cream. I should have returned it. That was a waste of money I’ll never buy it again.

This ice cream flavor compares to the premium ice creams but at an affordable price. Mix with chocolate or strawberries for additional flavor options.

What happened to Member's Mark Super Premium Vanilla ice cream? Did this replace it? We used to buy it all the time - it was one of our family's favorite vanilla ice creams. Hopefully Sam's Club will bring it back again!

Ok if you're wanting a creamy ice cream this isn't for you we like floats and this ice cream gets ice crystals when you use it that way in saying that imprefer an ice type ice cream over creamy so definitely a preference

Decent ice cream. I can't believe how expensive it is now! I can remember when it was $4.98, then 5.98, then 6.98 and now 7.98? It jumps by dollars.

Pros- it tastes great, is easy to scoop and reasonably priced. Cons-14g added sugar, high fructose corn syrup, 30% saturated fat and artificial flavoring.

The vanilla pail is good for making flavored shakes or frozen mixed drinks. It's not a premium ice cream; although, the cookies and cream flavor is delicious.

For the price the ice cream is okay but it's not great quality. Loaded with corn syrup and artificial flavors. It tastes artificial. Don't really recommend unless you just want something cheap.