Love the ice cream. Creamy and very tasty. Doesn't taste like your just eating ice. This has very much vanilla flavor to it. Great buy.

Delish! Very creamy with real vanilla taste! This size will last my family with 2 teenagers more than a weekend!!! Good Value!

Fructose corn syrup fake vanilla look at the crap on the ingredients it's horrible it's not real ice cream

This is okay with chocolate RX butter scotch syrup. On its own it’s rather bland. It’s not ffensive, but it’s not that great.

My husband loves ice cream so this is a favorite purchase at Sam’s. The ice cream is smooth and creamy. The flavor is delicious Vanilla.

We love the Sam’s club ice cream. Great product with a great price. We buy it all the time, love it!

My absolute favorite ice cream. Keeping trying others and come back to this classic. The taste is just so creamy and delicious!

Why does Sam’s Club make to types of ice cream ? Members Mark Supreme ice cream is delicious, the Members Mark ice cream in the pail is bland. I was very disappointed that they didn’t offer the Supreme ice cream online for delivery. It’s terrible.

I was surprised by the flavor of this ice cream. It's also a 5 quart pail which is almost impossible to find anymore. Price is comparative to a 4 quart pail at local grocery stores!

Decent budget ice cream, good for feeding a crowd of kids when you’re on a budget. However, you’ll know immediately that this isn’t the smooth high cream content (and more expensive) brand.