This was my wife and my favorite post dinner treat. Specifically the big 12 count pre cut edition of the dough. I had it down to a science. The cookies tasted great. It was perfect and we bought and ate way too much for our own good. I immediately could tell a difference. It’s not that the new dough is gross, per se. But it isn’t nearly as gooey and sweet. I don’t personally care about the new healthier ingredients. If I wanted a healthy snack I would eat spinach. To add onto the disappointing taste, the new recipe does not break off in its correctly portioned chunks leading to uneven cooking degrees. This is a classic case of “fixing” something that isn’t broken. We used to buy these cookies en made, but we won’t be buying anymore until the old recipe returns. I could care less about getting $5 back. They will loose much more of my money by sticking with this recipe.

We love Pillsbury cookies, but this dough is NASTY.  The kids were so excited to get fresh baked cookies for a treat, but gagged on these.  They got hard fast, tasted very cake-like, and the chocolate tasted like the off-brand gold foil coins that you get in a road side stand Easter Basket.  Not that I've had a bunch of that.  I have never been so disappointed in a product that I've felt the need to leave a bad review, but here's my first.  Oh yes, I'll be filling out the form for the money back too.  

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] They're not Grandma's cookies from scratch, but for the price/time saver/convenience, they're really good. It's close enough when you're having a cookie craving and don't have the time or ingredients to make the original. I love that you can safely eat the raw dough also.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I like this brand of chocolate cookies because you can eat the dough as is or bake them, when you bake them they are “boneless” cookies perfect to pair with ice cream or eat them plain, you can’t eat just one, so delicious!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Yummy, moist, and easy to bake! My daughter helps me fix these often. It is a weekly treat in our household. I would add that they are inexpensive to buy. I would highly recommend trying these delicious cookies. I really like these ready to bake chocolate chip cookies!

I finally checked this website to see if others felt the same way about the new recipe. And although the Pillsbury response says that most responses are positive, it appears to be completely the opposite. Are these comments being fed to the correct people? People that can make things happen - like bringing back the old recipe? At the very least, please provide a choice between the two - new and original. Then let the consumers pick. I’d be surprised if sales of the new recipe out performed the original recipe. We miss the great tasting cookies. Please Pillsbury, give us a choice!

The new recipe cookies are terrible. I've always chosen pillsbury over all others because they tasted the best... until now. This recipe tastes awful and I couldn't even take more than 2 bites when I usually eat atleast 3 or 4 cookies at a time. My family wouldn't eat them either and I wound up throwing them in the trash. I had another whole roll of it that I bought at the same time, that went straight to the trash too. Never again will I buy pillsbury cookies unless they fix the flavor. :-(

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this cookie dough! I’ve been eating it for years and it’s the closest to homemade cookies you’ll get. Just pop them in the oven and pour yourself a cold glass a milk and you have moist delicious cookies in no time.

Please make separate lines for eat "OR" bake cookies and do not keep the recipe combined like this. Yours were the only ones that baked up perfectly and had the best taste but now they taste like they are missing some important ingredient when baked. 0/5 do not recommend.

I think people are over exaggerating the difference in flavor of the new recipe. I didn’t really notice a difference in the flavor. What I did notice is that the dough is extremely sticky. It is really hard to get the precut cookies off the packaging. It sticks to the plastic and sticks to your fingers. It makes it really hard to get nice looking cookies and makes a mess.