This chicken salad is good, but I always add red grapes and pecans to give it a little more flavor. I like the convenience and the amount of chicken - it's easy to take to work for lunch.

My family loves chicken salad, but not this one. It seems a shame to do this to a nice rotisserie chicken. The chicken was fine, but the other ingredients didn't measure up. Also, we don't put raw onion in chicken salad at my house.

So disappointed in this “new” version of this salad! Won't buy it again. What happened to the original recipe? Why spoil a good thing? That's too bad. Very disappointed.

They changed the recipe and it doesn't taste like chicken salad anymore. Like others said, they added heavy relish and it tastes like tuna salad. Very disappointed.

It's OK, but I always add dried cranberries and almonds or pecans. Otherwise, to me it is too plain; maybe has too much mayo?? Even the smallest package is always too much for me as well since I live alone.

This used to be the best chicken salad around. i just bought the new recipe unknowingly today and its terrible the flavor is completely different and gross compared to what it was. I am extremely disappointed.

I received a free sample for my honest review. We love chicken salad and loved the opportunity to try this one. For us, this missed the mark just a bit. We’ve had the other chicken salad that Members Mark has had and like it better. This was good, but the recipe gave it a little bit of a tangy taste which we did not care for. I had it on a croissant which was good, but again did not care for the tanginess. Overall, I think many people will like this, it just wasn’t ideal for our liking. I give it 4 stars and recommend at least trying it.

I always loved this product! Not anymore. The last 2 times I bought it..most recently July 10 2026, it was awful. It's now actually mayonnaise and celery salad..no chicken chunks...just strings of dark meat chicken. I never waste food but I actually threw this out as there was very little protein value. ..just mayo and celery. Will not be buying it anymore. so sad

I used to love your chicken salad. Bought some a couple months ago and didn't like it. Tried another yesterday and its awful. Will never buy again until you go back to the original recipe. The changed version is purreed with to much vinegar and mayo. No thanks.

I rarely write reviews, but I feel so strongly about this item I just had to add myself to the list of other upset customers… If it was possible to give it negative stars, I would… js This item has been a staple %26 a near constant FAVORITE at my home for many years… anytime a new person tried it at my home, they frequently ended up joining Sam's just for the awesome chicken salad, it was just pretty simple : rotisserie chicken chunks, celery mayonnaise, maybe onion powder or actual onions, maybe a little salt and pepper or something, but it was DIVINE !!! Whomever changed it made a TERRIBLE decision, sometime around May 2026 I believe, is when it changed. I literally returned it to the store because it was so terrible. I knew it looked different but was willing to give it a chance, took one bite and drove it back to the store for a refund … Reminds me of cat food or something the way it looks, and it doesn't taste much better than what I imagine wet cat food tastes like… The kind lady who processed my return was not surprised AT ALL, she said many many folks were returning it because it's just plain horrible now, so so sad :*( PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD RECIPE !!!!!!!