We bought "good" Ribeye but it's now being sliced paper thin, so once I barely fried it, still had to throw it away

bought package of two today 8-18- 24. I have purchased select grade steaks more tender than these. Very dissatisfied with so called prime grade steaks.

I love these steaks! Coat them with olive oil and season with salt and pepper for a medium rare finish! They melt in your mouth! Mmmmm I will continue buying these always!

I guess I didn't learn my lesson the first time I bought these. The second purchase is like the first, not tender. Save your money and buy tenderloin for more quality.

They marked this garbage as Prime. It was barely choice. Four steaks, two very disappointed dinner guests and almost $75 wasted on this gristly, chewy beef disaster. Second time in the past 2 months. No more "Prime" meat from Sam's.

I have been buying these for over a year and have always met my expectations! Always tender and full of flavor. Butchers are always pleasant and helpful if you need a large order, I always call ahead.

these truly are the best steaks we can get at a grocery store. They're thick, well marbled, tender and cook like a dream. My husband and i always share one and put the other in the freezer in a food saver bag and it defrosts and cooks perfectly. We've always got one on hand!

I have never given Sam's a bad review until now. What has happened to my Sam's club - no fresh meat counter anymore. Bought pre-wraped prime ribeye steaks and they were terrible - grissley, fatty and tasted awful. No more wasting $22 a pound on something that should be prime and turns out you can't even eat it! Just think if we had company over. 🤯 We cut it up and gave it to the dog. We're going to find another meat market. ☹️

These came out so delicious. I rubbed them with salt the day before I cooked. I added pepper and garlic powder just before throwing them on the grill. I cooked indirect with charcoal and a piece of apple wood, and seared them at the end. This is so much better than going to a steakhouse.

I’ve ordered this item maybe 5 times, and have gotten diarrhea every time. I thought it might be something to do with all beef products during the pandemic, but I’ve had steaks from Sprouts without any problems. Sams club requires you to go in store for returns on food even though their website and policy says you don’t have to. So it’s wasted money.