These particular ribeye steaks were 2 star rated. The last batch purchased a couple of weeks prior was 5 star rated. There seems to be a lot of variation recently (2026). Sam's Club ribeye steaks were consistently excellent a few years ago. Not sure what happened.

Choice beef is a great choice. The steaks cut and packaged in the club rarely disappoint. I always marinate them before cooking in iron skillet, turning every 30 seconds. They are cooked through evenly, tender, and taste great. Beware, Sam's has been also selling pre-packed steak (sealed in a green package) and they are not as good. They are sold 2 in a pack, but are not as thick as the ones cut in the club. Nor where they as good. Tougher and did not have the same taste.

Nice cuts of beef. Very tender and juicy.

Great size and thickness was good

Steaks were good and tasty

Choice is not as good as prime.

Good quality. Wish the specs were on the package like grass fed pasture raised beef.

The cuts are perfect for grilling or even airfrying!

A great Steak. A great price!

Superb quality! Very tender!