I think pillows are hard to judge based on reviews as far as comfort goes because it is individual preference or what position you sleep in or physical problems a person might have that determines what is comfortable or not to a someone. I have been using these for about four years or more. I have a neck problem and I absolutely cannot use a big fluffy pillow. If I do I wake up in pain if I'm able to get to sleep at all. I loved these so much that I bought two extra sets in case Sam's quit selling them. They are pretty flat and I usually have to turn it once a day but I wanted something that was close to not using one at all so they are great for me. I can bunch it up under my neck so I get support there but the rest of my head is level with my spine. I just took a new one of my storage area to replace the one I've been using (probably for far too long). I've even taken one with me on road trips in case the hotel pillows are uncomfortable. I hope they keep making them. They are the best if you have neck problems like I do.

Hard and uncomfortable.

I've been looking for a good pillow for far too long. I had high hopes for this one but it's not supportive enough for me. Both my husband and I are side sleepers and both of us found that our heads sunk too far in to be comfortable. The materials seems ok, though. I've had some pillows where the memory foam clusters are very large but this one seemed to be a good size and not lumpy. Also, this pillow is surprisingly heavy! This pillow may work for you if you're not a side sleeper.

I can’t recommend these pillows enough. Polyester fill pillows are too flat, and too hot. Down pillows are comfy, but shed feathers constantly and fall flat quickly. Memory foam pillows are too hard. But memory foam chip pillows? THE BEST. Pros: stay relatively cool, stays full and spirituelle supportive. Retains shape after fluffing. Cons: the smell, which I personally don’t mind but I know other people are more sensitive to it. Smells like memory foam, what can I say? Heavier than a plain polyester pillow, but I like that. I am a side sleeper. I’m obsessed with these poles pillows. I was out of town for over a month and tried to order the same kind off of Amazon (Sams a was sold out). They only had a blend of memory chip and poly fill and it stocked. Too flat. Between my house, and my girlfriend, and the ones my dog tore up that first week, Ive bought several packs and always think about buying more.

Purchased these as replacement pillows so didn't use for a few months. When I unpacked and tried them I was very disappointed - they are terrible - very uncomfortable ! I have other Serta pillows but these are hard and lumpy. Thought if we were patient they would "break in" - nope! Gave 1 star but would like to give 0

Nice, very plump!

Not worth the money

These used to be GREAT pillows! They were my favorites. After buying for our bedroom, I slowly replaced all of the bedrooms in the house with these. I went back to buy new ones for our room and these are TERRIBLE! They are nothing like what I have purchased in the past. So disappointed.

I have a 3” gel mattress topper because I battle fibromyalgia pain. I couldn’t find the right pillow. They’re were all too soft or too hard. This one was just right. I’m sleeping the best I have in years. There is a slight smell when you first take them out of the box but I let them air out for a few hours and it was gone. If they came in King I would order another set! Great buy!

I tried this pillow in hopes that it did as advertised but went flat after the 1st night. Ended up putting both pillows in one pillowcase to have the effect I wanted. So 2 pillows for the price not bad but I thought I was getting 2 separate pillows for my bed and instead had to put together to use as one pillow. A bit of a disappointment.