So glad they brought this cake back. We love coconut cake, especially for Easter and Mother's day celebrations. It's delicious and so soft and moist.

Sorely disappointed!😢 This used to be the best cake ever. It doesn’t have the piped frosting around the top or bottom of the cake. Nothing between the layers. I believe it was previously 4 layers tall now only 3. The frosting is the best, if I didn’t want it all I could scrape some off, not now. Please make it like I remember!

Last year these were wonderful and was happy to see them again. But … not even close to what they were. 3 layers not 6, not a site of coconut custard, no icing between layers, not much coconut on the outside. I took a chance and ordered to be delivered or I would have passed. The cake itself is plain white cake, the frosting is more of a thick whipped cream type. Very little flavor. So extremely disappointed.

This cake was ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!! So moist, tender and flavorful!!! It tasted like it was make from scratch from an expensive Top Notch bakery! Will definitely be buying again.

I received a free sample for my honest review. The cake was so moist. the coconut flavor was tasty. there was an after taste that was present it didn't take away from the cake but was present.

While this cake was moist and tasty , I felt misled by the description. The description said 6 layers, the cake was only 3 layers. It also arrived noticeably lopsided. I’m usually impressed with Sam’s bakery products, but not this time.

I received a free sample for my honest review. if you're a coconut person, this cake is the perfect dessert. I love all things coconut so I'm a big fan of this. Coconut cake, coconut icing, coconut everywhere. It's fresh, light and moist.

I received a free sample for my honest review. Coconut is one of my favorite flavors and this cake didnt disappoint. Moist and perfect amount of icing. Definitely recommend.

I received a free sample for my honest review. The cake was moist and had a good flavor including the thin layers between the cake layers. There was something about the icing though that left a strange aftertaste in our mouths.

I am very lactose intolerant and every year this is the only cake I was able to enjoy, as it had absolutely no milk ingredients, and the buttercream frosting was so delicious. Yes, all that goodness meant jogging an extra mile or two everyday I had a slice but was always so worth it. We bought it religiously every single year for Easter. Lo and behold, I had a rude surprise this past April of 2022. Me and my wife bought one and invited our family over. We got to the cake and I took a few bites. I noticed it tasted off, really off. No sweetness, just tasted really bland with hardly no flavor. Then I heard my wife yell at me from the kitchen, “Don’t take another bite. Look at what they did to the cake.” She brought the label over and when I read it, I saw the horror as to what they did to the cake, the only cake I was able to eat due to its lack of dairy ingredients… they turned it into a whipped Coconut cake, which has the ingredients my body is allergic to. No buttercream? YUCK! Why Sam’s Club? WHY???? It made me very sick all night and the early morning hours and had to call off work due to the pain this change caused me, and without warning, as they at least could have warned consumers about the change on the label! But I must say, when I called the Bakery Supervisor and told her about what happened, she offered to give me a full refund, and that put a big smile on my face. A big thumbs up for her! Sam’s Club, please bring back the original Buttercream Coconut Cake next year and every year after that! It’s the only reason why we still buy a membership, among other things. The whipped cake doesn’t cut it! Reading this, I can hear people saying why wouldn’t I buy a Vegan cake at a health food store? Here’s the deal… they taste disgusting, they make you poop A LOT, and they make you poop things you never knew existed on God’s Green Earth! No thank you. Please bring back the original Buttercream Coconut Cake Sam’s Club.