Awful. Unfortunately, this was the worst cake I've ever tasted. It smelled like coconut, but it tasted like metal and artificial sweetener and flavoring. No real coconut flavor at all. The icing was a weird gummy substance that wasn't regular icing or whipped icing, but some sort of mess in between. Just plain awful. Save your $18 and avoid this cake.

This is the right amount of sweetness and is very moist. It reminds me of my granny's cake when I was younger. I hate that it is now a seasonal item (Easter) so I have half now and half for Mother's Day. It freezes well if properly wrapped and frozen.

They change the coconut cake. And not for the better. The filling has a bit of an odd taste. The icing is not as rich as previous and taste a little more frothy. I was expecting more buttercream. This used to be my go to cake that would fool people into thinking it was homemade. They will no longer make that mistake with this cake. so disappointed

A Delicious treat

This cake is wonderful!

It was great as always

I LOVE THESE CAKES, I'VE BEEN BUYING THEM FOR YEARS.. IF I DIDN'T KNOW BETTER, I'D SWEAR MY GRANDMOTHER WAS IN THE BACK BAKING THEM. THIS IS THE CLOSEST I HAVE COME TO HER HOME MADE CAKES & SHE PASSED OVER 30 YEARS AGO. PLEASE, PLEASE BRING THEM BACK!!!!

This is not the great Coconut Cake they use to sell a couple of years ago. The current one is not so great. I haven't bought Sam's Coconut Cake in a long time because they switched recipes, makers, I don't know what but sure wish they would go back to the 6-layer Cake they used to sell, which did have the current thick, very sweet butter cream frosting and only 3-layers. The original cake had a frosting that was lighter and not so thick or too sweet. I bought the cake yesterday on-line and it was delivered with other groceries. It's partly my fault because the photo's of the cake didn't look like the previous cake and if you scrolled through the additional photo's you would see a 3-layer cake. However, I didn't look through all the photo's, I was so happy because the description said it was a 6-layer cake. Please. whoever is in charge of Coconut Cakes, bring back the original 6-layer cake. I don't even like cakes that much, but the original Coconut Cake I could eat all day long.

My Very Favorite Cake

THE BEST