So we've been on a mission to try every Sam's Club cake. We get a cake once a month and this is our 5th cake. I have to say this is by far the worst cake. We've tried at Sam's. Usually, they cakes are 4-5 stars for us. This one was a total miss. No flavor in the actual cake. All the flavor is in the frosting, which is too sweet for everyone's taste in our household anyway. It's missing some fruits, nuts or something.

I had a bakery for 7 years till I had children and wanted to be their mother , but with that said…… my daughter in law purchased this cake and we had it as our only desert . She cut a piece for everyone and I took a bite. My brain could not process what was going on, it was soooooo bitter, the artificial coconut flavor was either too much or rotten or someone was trying to poison us but it was terrible …. Inedible! I told her to take it back but she refused so I’m here to tell you don’t buy this cheap cake that lady oks great but tastes like poison. So bitter so aweful .

I have been looking for coconut cake from local bakeries to avoid having to pay those ridiculous prices from Gold Belly. I really thought I might’ve found the one and was looking forward to trying it based on past reviews. A couple of people even stopped us to ask if it’s any good and I would hate to think that having in my cart might have encouraged them to get it. The cake is moist but heavier than what I expected. I was hoping to taste that creamy coconut flavor which I did not get, and the icing is way too sweet. I couldn’t even finish a thin slice I got for myself. I tasted mostly sugar which was disappointing. My son tried one bite and that was it for him. Well, the price was right so I just hope that some people at work might enjoy it, but definitely not for me.

I have bought this delicious cake for several years. Can't even express how good it is. I wish Sam's club had it year round but for sure at Christmas time as well. With the cocunut frosting (looking like snow) it could be decorated by the customer's for Christmas parties, dinners etc.

most coconut cakes from bakeries are almond, not coconut. For true die hard coconut lovers this is the one for you. I love it as is, with chocolate sauce, orange sherbet, chocolate ice dream... It is a huge cake do I cut in half and freeze. I also refrigerate, but cut a serving and let set out for a few minutes to mellow it out. However you slice it, it is delicious.

WOW!!! This cake is amazing!! It's so moist and tastes fresh. The flavor is spot on and not sickening sweet. If you love coconut you need this cake in your life. I'm going to get another one and freeze it in individual servings like I did with this one. Seriously, whoever came up with this recipe deserves an award.

I received a free sample for my honest review. This cake is delicious and delightful with coconut pudding layered in the cake and coconut on the outside. The frosting is very sweet but overall it’s a wonderful dessert for special occasions or for just because.

I received a free sample for my honest review. The cake is super moist and has a great balance of flavors. The richness of the coconut puts this over the top for me. I enjoy that the cake isn’t “heavy” to where I feel overly full after eating a slice. Will definitely be buying one of these to take to our family Easter gathering!

Typically we love this cake... this year it had very little of the coconut creme between the layers and was dry.

The frosting was too buttercream. The cake was a disappointment in taste. It was a large size, but just didn't taste very well.