Customer reviews for Member's Mark 10" Coconut Dessert Cake, 82 oz. forMember's Mark 10" Coconut Dessert Cake, 82 oz.
Most helpful positive review
2 customers found this helpful
5 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Soooo good---
Cynthia
Most helpful negative review
4 customers found this helpful
1 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Very Disappointed
Ms Bubba
770 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
- 1 out of 5 stars review3/25/2025We did not like this cake at all. I just bought it the day before a small family dinner. It has a VERY unpleasant artificial after taste. I would give it 0 stars if possible.
Coconut cake
Kari - 1 out of 5 stars review3/29/2024Purchased 3/23/24 for my mom’s birthday. Cake was horrible and we couldn’t eat it. It had a weird chemical taste like perhaps they used imitation coconut flavoring. Had to throw it out. Dog wouldn’t even eat it.
Worst cake ever!!!!!
Monique - 3 out of 5 stars review3/25/2024So they advertise this as having 6 layers of cake but it only has 3. Are they considering the frosting in between the cakes a layer, because to me a layer would be the cakes themselves. Very disappointed with the taste as well. Should have left it with a white cake and not a cake with coconut flavoring.
6 layers
Mr Tinkrtrain - 1 out of 5 stars review3/17/2025I looked so forward to trying this cake and now I regret biting into it. The icing was fine, but the cake was horrid. Whatever the filing was tasted like some crazy mixture of spices. It ruined the entire cake. Put pudding in the layers for moisture or layer with icing. Not that nasty concoction you presently smear in it!!!
N A S T Y
shopper1 - 2 out of 5 stars review4/21/2025This is not a coconut cake, there was a coconut scent but no flavor. The cake was vanilla as was the frosting. The only coconut I saw was the flakes they put around the outside. Also, it was advertised as a 6 layer cake and was only a 3 layer cake. Would not buy again.
Vanilla cake with coconut flakes
Darci - 2 out of 5 stars review3/31/2025The cake was tender and moist only in the center. The frosting was tasted sweet with no other flavor and coconut was sparsely distributed only on the frosting. There was no frosting between layers. And there was a "after taste" that was not pleasant. While the price was good for the size, it was not even worth that due to the taste. I should have paid attention to other reviews stating the same. If you're a coconut cake lover, don't disappoint yourself by trying this one!
Disappointing
Arbie - 2 out of 5 stars review4/11/2025I thought it would be like their coconut cupcakes although I haven't had any in a good while. I was highly disappointed the cake has a bitter taste to it. I would have brought it back but I have no transportation. I feel I wasted my money. The cake itself was moist unlike some of the other things I have purchased in the past.
Has a bitter taste
JAB - 1 out of 5 stars review4/13/2025Sam's use to have the best cocunut cakes, but this year it's the worst. Didn't notice how little coconut was on the cake until I got home and cut it. The filing between the layers was like uncooked cake batter with no favor. The layers were small. The icing had very little favor. Whoever prepared these cakes knew how bad these cakes were because they added too much coconut favoring to justify this was a coconut cake. Shame on Sam's for selling this. A waste of my $17.98. I won't make this mistake again by buying another cake from Sam's.
Worst cakes ever
mstee - 5 out of 5 stars review4/12/2025I have bought this cake for years from Sam's. It's a family favorite. I buy them to freeze too since they stopped selling them year round as they freeze well. I wish they would bring this cake back year round. My only suggestion of improvemment would be to cut cake layers in half and layer the coconut cream filling more. Still a really good cake. This cake is definitely better with the buttercream icing they use.
Yummy cake
shelley - 1 out of 5 stars review3/29/2024I wish I never wasted any money on this. It's not real buttercream icing and besides the flake coconut, the flavoring is extremely artificial and overwhelming. The cake texture was also very weird. Don't waste your money and definitely do not serve it to any guests.
Awful and a waste of money and calories
mmccollou - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/5/2024Cake was okay but the sweetness of the frosting was too much. This cake went in the trash!
Bad choice
Ed - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase5/6/2025This was my birthday cake
Great Birthday Cake
Carolina Girl - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/1/2025The best cake on the market we love it
bokey
bok - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/13/2024It was so delicious. Perfect amount of coconut and frosting. The cake portion was so fluffy.
Best coconut cake ever!
Beatrice - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/16/2025Cake was very good and moist. Icing tasted artificial.
Please change icing recipe!
rr - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/24/2024We love this cake!! It’s delicious!!
Best Coconut cake ever!!
Lynn B - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/13/2024Every year Sam’s doesn’t disappoint on coconut Easter cake
Delicious coconuts cake every bite is worth it
Gigi - 4 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase5/1/2025It was delicious but was not the same high cake we are used to purchasing.
Good
Ronda - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/3/2024This cake was very tasteless and not of the quality I'm used to purchasing from Sam's Club.
Tasteless Coconut Cake
NC Resident - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/30/2025Funny taste. Almost candy like.
Funny tasting
L Character