You don’t find carrot cake anywhere very often. This very moist and tasty. I hope they keep bringing it back

Just bought it this week and the nuts were not fresh from Newington, CT store. The cake itself is good. Sam’s club bakery is usually very good but this one item should be checked.

Worst carrot cake ever - I used to love Sam’s traditional carrot cake and had no idea they changed the recipe for this bar cake. Do not waste your money. I took a few bites on one piece and threw the entire remaining cake in the garbage.

For the cost I was hoping to be blown away. It’s good, but I doubt I’d buy again unless it was cheaper. The icing is very good, cake was moist, would have liked more nuts.

Too sweet for my taste. To be fair I never liked icing as that's also too sweet for my liking. For comparison, I loved the tres leches which is spongier, softer and using whipped cream instead. Would love to see a carrot cake where you can taste the ingredients but this is not it for me.

I tasted a sample a few weeks ago and promptly went to the bakery department and purchased one. It is delicious! My impromptu purchase was ill timed as I was heading out of town the next day. I didn't want to waste it so I cut it into serving sizes and added them to small freezer containers, hoping it would hold up to the freezing process. YES IT DID ! When I returned home, I grabbed one of my eight frozen serving containers and let it thaw. I will be purchasing this in the future!

The cake is dry and the frosting isn’t good. It doesn’t have the usual cream cheese richness, and it has a chemical aftertaste. I really wanted to love this as we got it for my birthday, but it was a disappointment. I absolutely would not recommend it. I don’t know if there’s inconsistencies in batches and maybe some taste better than others… but I won’t be giving it a second chance to find out.

We loved this cake so much we.

Where are the raisins???? No raisins in carrot cake means BAD cake

You must buy this it is so good!