Short of my homemade carrot cake, this is the best purchased carrot cake I have ever had. I bought it for my husband‘s birthday as carrot cake is his favorite. Homemade carrot cake is a lot of work with lots of steps in the process. So finding such a good carrot cake that I didn’t have to make was great! The cake is well worth purchasing. It’s moist and it has a very delicious cream cheese frosting. I plan to buy it for our next special occasion.

This cake was perfect! Had it delivered for Mother’s Day and we were not disappointed. Since there are 3 layers, a small piece was all you needed. Very moist and the icing was absolutely delicious!!! Perfect amount of sweetness. Will definitely buy again.

This is a good carrot cake, and it tastes great. The three stars aren't for the cake itself, but for the price. It's far too expensive for a simple rectangular cake that doesn't have the same thickness of an ordinary carrot cake.

The cake was not as good as it once was

I was really surprised how dry it was or maybe it was old, most of everything I buy from Sam’s is usually good especially your desserts

Did not care for the frosting. Was looking for more of a cream cheese frosting not one that taste like regular cake frosting

Carrot cake was stale. I will never buy this cake again.

Very dry and no flavor. Not to mention being extremely overpriced.

Few carrot shreds, no raisins, lots of fatty sugary frosting, cake texture fatty sugary How many real ingredients does this food item have?

Compared to their old carrot cake? This is an incredible disappointment. Shop elsewhere for a better carrot cake. Not as moist and the frosting has no flavor as the cream cheese frosting did on their rounds. It tastes more like a dried spice cake than a carrot cake. It was sad to see it go and as predicted, the replacement is an utter disappointment.