Compared to their old carrot cake? This is an incredible disappointment. Shop elsewhere for a better carrot cake. Not as moist and the frosting has no flavor as the cream cheese frosting did on their rounds. It tastes more like a dried spice cake than a carrot cake. It was sad to see it go and as predicted, the replacement is an utter disappointment.

It's was so NOT worth $17.99

This ain’t carrot cake. It’s horrible.

It was good but pretty dry

It was fresh. I would have liked the cake layers to be a little bit thicker. My husband liked it just the way it is. It freezes well.

Carrot cake is very flavorful and moist. Package is very poor. The bottom is very flimsy and unable to reattach the top.

I bought this cake for Easter and it did not really get eaten. It was very dry and had what seemed to be the carrot skin and those pieces were hard.

The Carrot cake is purported to be healthy, but these (my second) are just too sweet, frosting very thick. I will not buy again

This has to be one of the best carrot cakes ive ever had and this is my absolute favorite flavor always. It doesnt have too many walnuts or raisins, and the cream cheese icing is perfect. Id definitely purchase again

Excellent cake! Moist and not too sweet with just the right amount of icing. You can really tell it is carrot cake, and was enjoyed by the entire family.