The MM Pumpkin Crumb cake was great. The pumpkin cake was moist and flavorful. The crumb topping was thick and tasty. I can see how people would call it a dry cake. When I cut into it, the crumb topping did fall apart probably because it was so thick. I just scooped it onto the plate and enjoyed. Overall, for the holiday sale price of $8, it was a good buy and value. I would buy it again.

Despite the reviews saying it was dry and not very good, we bought this to try. It sounded good, and I'm so glad we didn't let the reviews stop us. This crumb cake is so delicious. It actually disappeared faster than the pumpkin pie, which is unheard of in our house! 2nds and 3rds were had by everyone. It must vary based on the club and ours just makes them really well.

Awful and very dry

Super all loved it

Absolutely terrible

This was horrible! So dry! We returned and were told they had several that had been returned. Don't waste your money!

Why bake a cake in a pie tin? The outer edge was dry. The crumb topping was a crunch topping. Very difficult to cut.

This "pumpkin cake" was a waste of money. It was extremely dry and had no flavor, it was like I was eating sawdust.

I literally cannot believe someone at Sam's Club thought this recipe was good enough to mass produce and sell. It's just a crumby cake, in a bad sense of the word.

This cake was dry and tasteless. My daughter didn't like the one I bought for her also. Not sure who the taste testers were for this product when it was manufactured. I returned both and got my money back. Just awful bakery item!!