I've been buying Pure Protein shakes for several years. I thought I would try the Members Mark brand since they're usually as good, if not better, than other brands. These shakes are really terrible!! I can usually tolerate any food but these, I ended up throwing them all away..... sad but true!!

I usually drink a different protein drink and was curious to see the difference between the two. This one is super chocolate-y and thick. There was a slightly chalky texture which was the one negative aspect. It was filling and kept my hunger at bay. I also like that there is 1 gram of sugar vs 30 grams of protein. Besides the texture, I would recommend this protein drink.

I give my kids protein drinks once in awhile because they are underweight and picky eaters. We usually use a different brand with a little less protein. As soon as we tried this shake we all knew it had a weird sweetener in it. It doesn’t taste good and leaves a bad aftertaste… this one’s not for us.

For some reason Fairlife has been hard to find, premier protein hard to find and limited flavors when they do have any in stock. I took a chance on these hoping they were as good but I just can't. Barely got through one and now I have this huge box sitting here. I can't even give them away.

The amount of protein in the shake is great, but you can taste the bad quality ingredients. It’s good for someone who just wants the most protein possible but for everyone else, it’s probably better to go with muscle milk for the same price and just cut the 5g of protein. At least you’ll be able to drink it without gagging.

I usually purchase Premier Protein shakes, but Sam's fooled me with their Members Mark knockoff. I didn't catch it until I drank the first shake. I knew immediately that I messed up. The Members Mark shakes flavor profile is off and has a distinctively unpleasant aftertaste. You will not fool me again.

I ordered these because the delicious Fairlife protein shakes were out of stock. This is the worst Member’s Mark product I’ve ever tried. I’ve choked down two and think I’m probably going to throw the rest of the case away. They are awful. Horrendous. Sam’s needs to go back to the drawing board with this product.

Well... I have had worse tasting protein shakes but the smell of these are gross. Each drink i took smelled like mold and mildew. Of course it was not molding but maybe it was the carton. It was smooth and creamy and very chocolaty however for me the smell took over.

I love this protein shake. It’s the perfect portion, easy to just grab from the frig, the chocolate flavor is very good and I feel full after drinking one container. I like that most of the daily nutritional values are only 25% since I also get many of these vitamins and minerals from other sources throughout the day. I also appreciate that it has only 1g of sugar and reasonably low sodium.

Please don't mistake this drink as a substitute for Premier Protein. The taste while drinking is okay, but the aftertaste is blah and chalky. I noticed the price of PP had been increasing so I wasn't surprised Member's Mark came out with their own. Yes, it is cheaper, but you get what you pay for. I won't be purchasing this again.