Does not compare well with Fairlife chocolate protein drink. Has a chalky texture (especially if you don't shake it extremely well) and the taste is a bit artificial. Costs about 30 cents less per bottle, but I will continue to buy Fairlife as long as it is available.

Way tooooo sweet taste generic to thick nothing about this shake is good!!! I do not recommend it!!! Stick to the premier brand!!! Don’t usually try off brand since it was Sams Club thought I’d try it and goodness it’s awful tooo awful!!! 5 year’s on premium & still nothing can compare to it!

Tried a case of these after comparing the ingredients to Premier, which it's obviously supposed to imitate. The ingredients and nutrition are pretty much identical, but the taste is not. Chalky and sickeningly sweet with artificial sweetener aftertaste. How could you screw these up so badly Sams? Throw them out and go back to the drawing board!

This Member's Mark Protein Shake is a great energy booster. Amazingly it has a great taste, and has vitamins and minerals that you need. Since I'm a diabetic this shake only has 1g of sugar which is great for us diabetics. I highly recommended for a daily supplement so you can feel energize all day long.

I needed an on the go meal alternative. Members Mark cocolate protein shake contains 30g of protein and many additional nutirents which is great. Giving this 4 stars because on the taste side its ok, not very chocolaty tasting but worked wonderfully for what I needed.

There were mixed opinions in my household about these. The adults seemed to like the flavor and thought they tasted good. The teenagers did not care for the flavor or the texture. Overall I would say that the flavor is good and is packed with good nutrients in a small bottle.

I give my kids protein drinks once in awhile because they are underweight and picky eaters. We usually use a different brand with a little less protein. As soon as we tried this shake we all knew it had a weird sweetener in it. It doesn’t taste good and leaves a bad aftertaste… this one’s not for us.

I usually drink a different protein drink and was curious to see the difference between the two. This one is super chocolate-y and thick. There was a slightly chalky texture which was the one negative aspect. It was filling and kept my hunger at bay. I also like that there is 1 gram of sugar vs 30 grams of protein. Besides the texture, I would recommend this protein drink.

I have been buying premier protein chocolate shakes for years, and I really love using them as the creamer in my coffee. I thought I would try the member's Mark brand since they were cheaper, but they are terrible! They have that very chemical sweet taste and I wound up just dumping out the whole cup of coffee. I'm going back to the premier protein.

In protein shakes the chocolate flavor makes its or break for me, this one is average. The shake starts smooth and is medium bodied, it does tend to leave a slight aftertaste. Nutrition wise, this one covers all the marks for me. Taste wise, I prefer a different brand that Sam's also carries. So bottom line is, if protein shakes are a daily part of your nutrition, then this is a solid budget friendly middle of the road option, but it could taste a little better.