This is not very tasty. My least favorite protein shake. I was hoping it would compare to premier protein shakes, but it fails miserably when it comes to taste comparison.

I was very surprised by the taste. I figured it would be like any other thing that is good for you and taste bad. It has a very rich chocolate taste almost like a thick milk shake! Yes, You can tell the protein taste in it but it is very tolerable! My wife actually took a banana and a protein shake and mixed in a blender....Awesome! I have tasted other brands of these protein shakes and threw them away. These are 100% better than any of the other name brands out there!

There were mixed opinions in my household about these. The adults seemed to like the flavor and thought they tasted good. The teenagers did not care for the flavor or the texture. Overall I would say that the flavor is good and is packed with good nutrients in a small bottle.

A little aftertaste that stays with you. Sugar and protein contents are great for me as I am diabetic. Container size is spot on and filling.. It is a a great supplement in place of a meal or refreshing after a walk on the treadmill. Although chocolate is not what I would have thought I would like, turns out that it was good, not too strong. I think a different flavor may have upped my opinion of the product.

Meh, it's okay, at best. As a drinker of Premier Protein Shakes, I was hoping these would taste as good, if not better, so I could get more for my dollar. Unfortunately, even as frugal as I am, the chalky taste (yes, i shook it VERY well) left me with a not-so-good aftertaste. I'll stick with Premier Protein, but thanks for trying.

I was sent this to try and unfortunately because its whey based I couldn't try it (whey = pure lactose) but my adult diabetic son could. He loved them. He said they were very chocolaty, creamy, smooth and filling. He will definitely be trying out some of their other flavors. I wish they made plant based Members Mark protein shake and powders!!!

I really wanted to like this, because unlike fa!rlife protein drinks, these are always in stock. But they are not as good. They’re basic, chalky and exactly what you would expect from the majority of protein drinks on the market. I will say the chocolate flavor is very good, but the chalkiness and the aftertaste is not my favorite

I like the higher-priced, better known protein shake, but this one is fine all on its own. It's perfect for a "full" feeling and assurance of good nutrition. Great for times when you can't have a big meal or don't want one. Shelf-stable, and great chilled.

Does not compare well with Fairlife chocolate protein drink. Has a chalky texture (especially if you don't shake it extremely well) and the taste is a bit artificial. Costs about 30 cents less per bottle, but I will continue to buy Fairlife as long as it is available.

The price is right and you receive three more shakes per box, but that's where the similarities end. By my standards, the shakes are not creamy at all. They have the consistency of store bought chocolate milk. The chocolate taste is OK, but it is somewhat strong and a little bitter to me. And as the other reviewers have stated there is a strong after taste I can't really describe it but it's not very pleasant and does taste somewhat like medicine. So will I buy these again? Probably not as they are not typical Members Mark quality.