I ordered a two-tiered cake for my mom’s 80th birthday. The buttercream was really delicious and not overly sweet and the cake, vanilla on bottom and chocolate on top, was moist and tasted great. We were really pleased with the purchase.

I picked up a two tiered round cake and the cake itself was wonderful, but they did not put any icing where the top layer sat on top of the second layer so you could just see black and silver so we had to buy icing and do that part ourselves so that was disappointing

New website ordering places unreasonable limits on customization. Color combos are awful. Timing on pickup is deceptive- when finalizing order, the pickup time will be different by day(s) not hours. I just wanted all white everything (icing, borders, decor - impossible)! We used to love Sam’s cakes but now we’re on the hunt for an alternative.

I ordered a plain 2-tier cake that I planned to decorate myself. Cake was delicious but there was a major fail in the frosting. Frosting on top was not smooth all over and when I questioned it, the staff member said that's how it comes out when there's no decoration. Not true! With or without decorations, frosting can be smoothed out. Also I could see the plate between the 2 layers because it wasn't covered completely by the frosting. Fortunately I was able to cover it with my decorations. I've ordered this cake before and it was perfectly frosted, making it easy to decorate. This time I had to decorate to fix and cover up.

I called to cancel this wedding cake as the wedding had been called off. They told me that I could not cancel an online order that if i just did not pick up the cake i would not be charged. Fast forward to the Monday after pickup day and the money was taken out of my account. I have made 6 phone calls and have been lied to 5 different times about my refund but long story short I'm not getting my money back. I definitely would not recommend ordering a cake online with Sam's club. And their online customer service is awful

I ordered this cake 4 days before my daughter's intimate wedding. It was done all online. The cake was ready when promised. It looked amazing. I was impressed with how beautiful it looked. I ordered vanilla on top and chocolate on the bottom. It tasted as good as it looked. I would definitely recommend Sam’s Club for this cake!

This is the perfect blank canvas cake to make into whatever you choose. Perfect size and taste great to.

The cake was our wedding cake. I ordered all white and added flowers myself. The cake was delicious.

Cake was delicious and perfect. I was able to add floweres to it and it looked like a professional decorated it.

Brown Cake board showing between layers. Not smooth. Not as pictured on website. Will not buy again.