This was the perfect wedding cake! It was delicious and affordable. We wanted something very simple and it checked all the boxes. Looked professional and sleek.

Moist, delicious - always get my cakes from Sam’s! This one was a hit with black frosting - turned our mouths black, too! lol - went with something they had in the catalog but changed frosting from white to black - super happy with end result!

Sam’s custom cakes are fantastic! The price alone! The cakes I’ve purchased have all been good. I have upgraded on my own from the available selection. Always as advertised and on time.

We are going to use this for a weekend next month and did a trial by buying one ahead of time. It looks and tastes great!! Way better than the $750+ for a wedding cake from a cake shop.

I loved the way it looked but I was disappointed that it only came in buttercream. I loved it when you had the option of whipped cream or buttercream. The price was reasonable. I guess I got what I paid for!

Cake flavors were good! Presentation was horrible. Asked for a basic white frosting cake beaded boarder. cake was crooked and boarder did not cover imperfections between tiers.

I do not recommend the Rockford IL location for a wedding cake. We ordered one and it was the wrong flavor and it was completely lopsided. The edging was also not even. It’s cheap but they did a bad job

This wasthe first time buying a tiered cake from Sam's Club and it was an excellent experience. Customer service was great! The taste was delicious! Price wise it was affordable. Definitely recommend!

Frosting was crazy sweet. And the top tier was not centered it was falling off the back. I was really displeased. Normally their cakes are amazing but this wasn't just epic fail.

Overall, the cake was good and decorated nicely. However, the word count in the area where you can type your message when customizing your cake was not enough. It was hard to describe both what I wanted to be written on the cake AND the specific color of frosting I wanted in the same message area because of the word limit. Other than that, the cake was good overall.