Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Rastelli’s Prime Beef Rib with Two Side Dishes, Frozen, 10 lbs. for
Rastelli’s Prime Beef Rib with Two Side Dishes, Frozen, 10 lbs.

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 31-40 of 57 reviews
Dec 7, 2023
Martin
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Bad cooking instructions

It would probably have been better if the cooking instructions were correct. I followed it them to a T and it came out raw. When I cut into it blood flowed all over the cutting board. I forced myself to take 3 bites and threw the $120.00 piece of meat in the trash. If I ever decide to do it again I will try about 45 minutes instead of the 25 on the instructions. The side dishes were absolutely awesome, best mashed potato's I have ever had.

Helpful?6D2E3NORTTBD13608113140
Apr 6, 2023
june
3 out of 5 stars review

Issue with side dish

When received I am unable to use the mashed potato side as the plastic cover was torn and product was exposed. So discarded. Saw no evidence that this was a shipping issue except cardboard sleeve was looser than the mac dish.really did not order for anything but the prime rib so not much issue. will review roast after serving.

Helpful?6D2E3NORTTBD13608113140
Jan 5, 2026
CYNTHIA
4 out of 5 stars review

Side dishes a lot to be desired

Items arrived right on time in a very frozen state. Thawed in the fridge as directed. The mashed potato container had cracked, draining all the liquid out. The butter was hard to spread, had to literally putty it on. The meat turned out perfect. Would prefer to buy other side dishes than the ones that came.

Helpful?6D2E3NORTTBD13608113140
Dec 29, 2025
JAMES
2 out of 5 stars review

Toughest Prime Rib I have ever eaten

The meat was the toughest Prime Rib I have ever eaten. We cooked it per the instructions and the finished temperature was per the instructions. Very disappointed in the meat. Potatoes and Mac %26 Cheese were great. Packaging was terrible. Styrofoam cooler virtually destroyed in transit - contents were still frozen. Do not recommend.

Helpful?6D2E3NORTTBD13608113140
Nov 8, 2023
Topdog149
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Read fine print

Thought it was a ten pound prime rib with two side not a 5 pound prime rib with two two and half pound sides

Helpful?6D2E3NORTTBD13608113140
Dec 25, 2025
THERESA
5 out of 5 stars review

yum

excellent. i used the seasoning packet and garlic butter. came out w a perfect crust. i had to turn my oven back on at the end to get it to the right temperature. an oven safe meat thermometer is needed.

Helpful?6D2E3NORTTBD13608113140
Dec 25, 2025
Mildred
4 out of 5 stars review

Prime rib was great. Mac and cheese and potatoes were a great disappointment. Potatoes were runny and lumpy, Mac and cheese had no flavor at all. I'll never order sides again.

Helpful?6D2E3NORTTBD13608113140
Dec 27, 2025
Penny
3 out of 5 stars review

tadty but tough

meat was flavorful but tough even hard to slice. Anticipated tender feast very disappointed. covering with butter prevented an au jus and for me too spicy followed direction but it was a fail

Helpful?6D2E3NORTTBD13608113140
Dec 26, 2025
CHRISTEE
3 out of 5 stars review

I was very disappointed with my purchase. I have bought this before from another merchant and it was delicious. This had more fat than meat and very little taste. FYI it was cooked per your directions.

Helpful?6D2E3NORTTBD13608113140
Nov 29, 2024
cropped
3 out of 5 stars review

Mediocre

Way too much rosemary, covered up beef flavor. Very disappointed in the instant potatoes and sweetened mac& cheese. I can go to local place and get better deal, won't waste money on ordering this again

Helpful?6D2E3NORTTBD13608113140