I cooked two of these on the grill to a medium temperature and the meat was as tough as shoe leather. It was tough to cut it with a steak knife! I am returning the balance for a refund.

Grilled these for visitors and it was embarrassing. Meat was tough to chew and had very little flavor. Very disappointing for Angus steaks. Have had these many times before and they were delicious then.

I bought 6 steaks to have one for each person for 3 adults and 2 teenage boys who can put away food lol. These 1 inch to 1 and half inch thick steaks didn't shrink when cooked to medium well, very light pink center. They couldn't finish their steaks, only the one I gave a smaller piece too finished theirs haha. I couldn't eat but a quarter of mine haha. I just put some course salt all over them and rubbed it in and onion powder and cooked on a charcoal grill without match light, and they were juicy and flavorful! Really good.

First time I ever bought steaks at Sams. The price is great, but they were still a bit chewy which I found disappointing. They were thick so I grilled them 5 minutes on each side as was suggested and they were cooked perfectly, but wish they were more tender.

Bought a three pack of these and then a four pack. Nice marbling and thicker than supermarket steaks. Excellent when tenderized and seasoned with butter/oil/seasoning mixture. I've been pan frying these on a gas stove and have had good results with every steak.

I have never had bad steaks from Sam's Club until now. These were tough and tasteless, even though they were grilled to a perfect Medium-Medium Rare. I will not purchase steaks from here again. For the money paid, these should have been sooooo much better.

I purchased a 4 pack and prepared 2 over the weekend. I grilled them to medium but they were not as tender as the steaks used to be. Very lean with little marbling at all. Next time I will pay the extra and try the Prime which are sold separately at the butcher case.

I usually get the prime tenderloin which is excellent - decided to try the Choice Angus Strip Steak - 4 steaks in the package - all like shoe leather. Tried the grill, the oven, sous vide - nothing can help these steaks. One of the worst cuts of beef I have ever experienced. Don't insult your dog with this junk!

I only eat NY strip steak and I feel cheated out of $35. This makes me not want to renew my membership and start ordering the few things I get there online. That's so messed up that you put another cut off meat and then call it NY strip steak... About to start researching if I can but the things I normally get somewhere else

The quality is good and the taste is best when seasoned with xtra virgin olive oil, fresh ground pepper corn and course sea salt or kosher salt. NOTHING ELSE!!! Grill direct heat turning once to get a good charred crust on each side. Let rest and serve Delicious