I had been craving manicotti for a couple of weeks. Seen this at Sam's and thought I'd give it a try. I bought it for myself and I got 3 meals out of it. It tasted very good!!! Cheaper than the resturaunts you can buy it in.

Great dinner option! Tastes delicious! The only thing I would note, is that the directions are off for us. We cook it about 20 minutes longer than listed in the directions.

Previously this was my go to for a quick and easy dinner with left overs. This past time, purchased 09/13/2026 they changed something, the cheese was weird tasting and there was not enough tomato sauce as well as very little mozzarella on top. It's a shame that Sam's decided to cut corners. Tried it and ended up throwing it all out, complete waste of money.

The manicotti from Sam's has been a family favorite for years, until it changed to this new recipe. What was an easy dinner that never had any complaints from even the pickiest of 7 year olds, turned into the most disappointing meal we have had in awhile. Please change it back!!

I'm not sure why changes were made to this dish. It used to be delicious. This time we had to throw half of it away because the filling did not taste like ricotta at all. It was a weird creamy texture and the taste was not good. My son said it kept making him gag. The red sauce on top was also different and not as good as we have had in the past. I was so looking forward to having this dish and was absolutely disappointed. I will not buy this again unless I know they change it back to what it used to be made with.

This was horrible - way too salty. We bought it the first time and thought maybe it was just a fluke and bought it the second time. It was just as bad. We threw out this one as well. I really wanted to like this meal because everyone loves pasta. Very disappointed.

This used to be the best quick meal to get at Sams. After not having it in a while we were so excited to sit down to dinner to enjoy......not this. Neither of us finished what we put on our plate. the cheese is awful and has a weird sea food flavor for some reason? The ricotta is NOT ricotta and has a very strange mushy texture. Needless to say, super disappointed.

My husband used to love this and eat it all over the course of a couple days. The last few times he ended up throwing some out, and we thought that it was just cause he added too much extra cheese. Today he had it without any extra cheese and then told me he didn't like it or not to buy it again (we used to buy extra for the freezer) After looking at the reviews, it appears that they recently made a recipe change. Please bring back the old recipe and if you do, please update the listing so we know it's good to buy again

I'm not sure what they changed in their prepared manicotti, but it definitely is not the same. It used to be so good and now I couldn't even finish eating it. The sauce is different and the cheese it's stuffed with is awful, doesn't even taste like it has ricotta cheese in it anymore! Will not buy again.

After hearing how good this dish is, and reading some of the good reviews, I decided to try it myself. I was very disappointed, because I do not agree with any of the good reviews. I found it to be very bland. Before serving it to my family, I had to do a lot of “doctoring” to this dish.