My family enjoys this manicotti quite a bit. But the first time I tried it, I followed the directions to bake at 350 for 30 minutes, covered with foil. When I took it out of the oven, it was still cold in the middle and the cheese was not melted at all. The next time I made it, I baked it UNcovered and it came out perfect, with melted and slightly browned cheese on top. So in my experience, as long as you bake it uncovered, it comes out great.

This is so unbelievably delicious and easy! we have this at least twice a month and there is always one in our freezer. The cheese filling is really good, and they don't skimp on it. Excellent tomato sauce topping and cheese. It is two meals for me and hubby. If I wait too long to serve this, he will request it. Better, easier, and cheaper than I could make myself.

Yes!! It's a mess to have to transfer this into an oven safe dish and half the sauce sticks to the plastic tray. The food is very good but I buy ready made for the convenience and these plastic trays are a mess, Bring back the oven safe bottom please! Same for the rest of the ready made meals. Gave 3 stars until the convenience of the container is back, I would give it 5 stars otherwise. Oh, and put the directions on top in larger print, You have to flip the container over and use a magnifying glass to read it.

I have to say, these were terrific but I prefer meat sauce so I quickly made some meat sauce to top them off. If you like your red sauce without meat, then you’ll like these as is. I’m just not a fan. The manicotti was great though. No need for me to stuff manicotti anymore, I’ll just buy these.

We love this dish. It's good, and easy. However, the first couple times my husband cooked it, I thought he was doing something wrong because it was cold in the middle. So I cooked it tonight and luckily came here to read reviews because I thought something didn't seem right when I pulled it out of the oven, and as other reviewers have mentioned, the 350 degrees for 25-30 min won't work. The cheese isn't melted and it's cold in the middle. I cooked it for 30 min as instructed and now I'm on another 15 minutes uncovered. It seems to be looking really good now. I took off a star for this. I'm disappointed Sams hasn't fixed the cooking instruction issue. Seems like it would have saved me and others time.

Instructions say cover, 350 for 25-30 min. Nope, not even close. Cooked 30 min, cheese not even melted. Uncovered at 400 for additional 10 min. Thermometer says 100 degrees in the middle, middle cool to touch. Additional 10 min and the middle was warm, but not hot. The flavor was good, but was extremely annoyed as we were running late for dinner anyways. Oven was preheated, cooked garlic bread as directed and it cooked as expected, so its not the oven.

This product used to be great, but SAM's had to have modified the recipe with horrible results. I took a tray back, but just recently tried again thinking maybe there was a preparation mistake. It was equally horrible and I put it through the disposal.

This has the potential to be better. Needs much more seasoning and thicker sauce. The sauce gets watery. The ricotta cheese inside is ok. I think it you paired it with some chicken parm, the blandness of the manicotti would be ok. Would I buy again? Possibly, for a night when I don’t want to cook.

Excellent value! This is on regular rotation but where it shines is on our RV trips. I bake it up with some meatballs and portion out for quick meals when we are just spending a night on the road as we transit to our ultimate destination. We get 4 very filling portions, it's a great deal and way better than any frozen meal. It also wonderful that I've been able to find this at every Sam's during our travels.

First of all for the Debbie's saying this doesnt taste Italian, this doesnt taste home made, yada yada its obvious it wont because fresh is always better than pre made. If your wanting good simple fast and convenient manicotti this is it, yes better than Olive Garden whoever actually thinks OG is better than this has not tasted authentic Italian food. This is a good option and do recommend adding extra sauce since it is missing extra sauce for the amount that is included. If you add sausage its even better. You can make this convinient meal as extra as you want or as is. My entire family loved this and will keep buying it. If your a cheesy person I recommend this.