There was absolutely no real lime or real key lime flavor at all, tasted like it was all imitation flavoring if any.

Sam's Key lime pie is always a family favorite. Great taste and perfect spring dessert. It's a big hit every time.

It appears the recipe has changed, as this lacked the tart "spark" of previous key lime pie purchases.

This was the best pie I’ve had in a long time. Very good flavor and there was nothing left on pan.

Purchased the Key Lime Pie for my job function the pie(s) was great had to go back for a second pie. The pie was refreshing and oh so good actually could've had a third pie!!!

I purchased this for a friends birthday 🎂, he loves Key Lime pie, but I never tasted it, I asked the ladies in the bakery dept on their opinion and they said it was good, it took a chance, He Loved it .

The pie was good enough for a Sam's Club bakery but they need to adhere to the original recipe. The lemony taste was missing, and the coloring was not a true Key Lime Pie.

This is a delight to try. This fresh key lime pie with a silky smooth texture will leave you wanting more. And for the price you can skip the messy kitchen clean up Win win!!

We have been buying this pie for many years and we are SOOO disappointed at their recent changes. They reduced in size at least 25% keeping the price the same. BUT worst than that they changed the recipe. It tastes like artificially flavored with rotten bitter aftertaste, NOT a refreshing key lime taste. AND it was poorly made, not fully mixed with bits of gelatin floating around. A complete fail, we tossed in the trash. I have no doubt you just lost many customers on what use to be a great product.

I was so excited to try this pie. For me it's Too Sweet! Couldn't actually taste the “Lime “ flavor! Also a little Less Whipped Cream “ decoration might also cut out so much Sugar! .Considering how much I like-sweets I'm surprised this pie is too sweet for me. However, the pie size is very generous, and the price is perfect! My suggestion is Less Sugar and a bit more Lime Flavor.