It was absolutely delicious

excellent flavor & value

One of the best pre-made key lime pies I've ever bought. Not overly sweet and not bitter. Creamy texture - not as creamy as some restaurant-made pies I've had, but very good for a store bought. Better than the frozen key lime pies I've purchased.

This key lime pie is amazing. For the price, this is hands down the best way to indulge in this heavenly dessert.

Sam's Key lime pie is always a family favorite. Great taste and perfect spring dessert. It's a big hit every time.

This was the best pie I’ve had in a long time. Very good flavor and there was nothing left on pan.

There is some chemical in this pie that tastes bitter and turns my stomach. I love key lime pie and cheese cake, but this one is not for me.

Delicious but not "real" key lime filling, excessive cream, thick but delicious crust, reasonable price and ideal size

At first it was okay, not tart like key lime. After the initial piece the scent of old oil appeared and the taste came asking with it. Since I do bake, I recognize the scent of cheap shortening which likely what was used in making all of that whipped cream. Totally ruined the whole pie.

Very Good - But Inconsistent with different stores. I typically shop at one store and have bought this pie several times at that store and it is delicious! Just the right amount of tartness and just the perfect amount of sweetness. A decent amount of whipped cream. I have raved about it to many people. But recently I picked one up on my way to a friend's house and it was disappointing. Much more tart, almost sour, and the amount of whipping cream was skimpy. Luckily she had some whipping cream on hand but even that didn't help with the tartness. Yesterday I had one delivered from another store, so now a third store and the same as the second; skimpy on whipping cream and extra tart. Maybe the first store is the one that's "wrong" but it's the better one so I guess I have to always purchase from that store because it's a 10 out of 10 from that store.