The Sam's Club Key Lime Pie is very tasty, not too sweet not too tart, just right. Unfortunately, the pie has shrunk over the last few months, they used to be noticeably larger.

Excellent product and price point! A solid choice and crowd pleaser for easy entertaining. I'm a Native Floridian and this is next to perfection for the authentic flavor and crust. Also good with fresh berries!

I purchased this for a friends birthday 🎂, he loves Key Lime pie, but I never tasted it, I asked the ladies in the bakery dept on their opinion and they said it was good, it took a chance, He Loved it .

We have purchased Key Lime Pie from private bakeries in Venice, Florida, Bethany Beach, DE and Harrisburg, PA and this Sam’s Club Key Lime Pie got the “This is really good” seal of approval from my pie loving son and will be his birthday pie this year!!! The rest of us will have cake, he will have Sam’s Key Lime Pie…at half the price of bakery pie’s!

Beware, this pie is very good. It is as they say, “To Die For”. Make sure you have enough people to help you eat it, or you may eat it all. If that’s the case, you’ll have to freeze it or you’ll keep going back for more. It is sweet and richly flavored.

The key lime part of the pie and the crust was good, however the “whipped cream” on top tasted more like chemicals than cream. It doesn’t even dissolve in water in the sink! It’s more like Twinkie filling, not a fan.

The Key Lime pie is nice and tart but the white stuff on top is not. I don't know what it is but it taste like something artificial and is stiff and a little rubbery and doesn't melt in your mouth. Whatever it is it needs to be replaced with either real whipped cream or real meringue. I just try to scrape it off.

I wish that Keylime pie would have more Keylime tartness to it. It just seems a little bland little disappointing. Come on sam's club You can do better.

Sorry, this pie is just not that good. Hardly any lime flavor and they use that cheap fake tasting whipped topping not made with real cream.

This did not meet my expectations . The lime flavor was barely recognizable. The whip cream tasted very artificial