Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Member's Mark 10" Key Lime Pie, 41 oz. for
Member's Mark 10" Key Lime Pie, 41 oz.
4.6 out of 5 stars
stars
6,350 ratings1,541 reviews
  1. 5 stars82% (5,176)
  2. 4 stars8% (519)
  3. 3 stars5% (305)
  4. 2 stars2% (140)
  5. 1 star3% (210)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 31-40 of 1,541 reviews
Dec 22, 2023
Rob
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Too Sweet

There was too much sweetener in the whip cream and pie filling to enjoy. Most desserts don’t last long in our household. The pie stayed for more than a week. Pass on this.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Mar 24, 2026
Candid Critic
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Our favorite

This is hands down the best store bought brand keylime pie. It's also priced great and there's enough to feed your whole family.its also my go to to take to potlucks and gatherings.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Jun 24, 2024
Kathy in Denver
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

The worst pie offered at Sam's!

Almost returned this pie. My husband and I agreed the taste lacked key lime, the crust and cream were lackluster and it generally was well below average. We will not purchase it again.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Sep 27, 2025
BC
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

The best store bought key lime pie

This key lime pie is out of this world GOOD. Not too sweet but, the real winner that brings everything together is the buttery graham cracker crust! Highly recommend

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Nov 11, 2025
ShirleyKL
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Tart Key Lime Pie but bad topping

The Key Lime pie is nice and tart but the white stuff on top is not. I don't know what it is but it taste like something artificial and is stiff and a little rubbery and doesn't melt in your mouth. Whatever it is it needs to be replaced with either real whipped cream or real meringue. I just try to scrape it off.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Jul 3, 2026
anonymous
1 out of 5 stars review

Something has changed

I used to love, love, love this key lime pie. But something has changed with the recipe. It now has a super strong chemical taste, I am guessing it's from the artificial lime flavor? I won't buy again….and although it's better for my waistline, my disappointment is immeasurable.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Jul 21, 2026
anonymous
1 out of 5 stars review

Changes Ruined a Great Pie

We have been buying this pie for many years and we are SOOO disappointed at their recent changes. They reduced in size at least 25% keeping the price the same. BUT worst than that they changed the recipe. It tastes like artificially flavored with rotten bitter aftertaste, NOT a refreshing key lime taste. AND it was poorly made, not fully mixed with bits of gelatin floating around. A complete fail, we tossed in the trash. I have no doubt you just lost many customers on what use to be a great product.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Jul 4, 2026
T Review
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Keylime goodness

This pie was really good, not quite grandma's. The blend of sweet and tart are very good.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Jul 11, 2026
DMeeks
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Like being at Sunday dinner

Like Grandma use to make!!

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Jul 19, 2026
Dee
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Good tasting

Right size and taste better than the supermarket pie

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147