This Sam’s pie has no business being this good. It is legitimately one of the best pies I’ve ever had.

This is such a great key lime pie! Nice and tart! We put it in the freezer so we can take a slice whenever we want!

Best key lime pie I’ve eaten. I always buy one or two to take to family gatherings. So glad you are carrying it again.

Too sweet for our household. Sugar overload from crust to filling. If you love sugar, this is for you!

Texture was smooth and silky, however it lacked the taste of key lime. After having one small slice I returned the pie. Thanks for Sam’s great return policy.

The pie was good enough for a Sam's Club bakery but they need to adhere to the original recipe. The lemony taste was missing, and the coloring was not a true Key Lime Pie.

The member's Mark key lime pie I bought from Sam's I was very excited because I had seen some reviews talking about it was so good. Not true it was terrible I will never ever buy another key lime from Sam's club. It was a total waste of money

Hands down probably one of the best pies around . We love key lime pie . We live in south Florida so we have tried many and this is at the top . And for 9.99 can't beat it .

I ate the whole pie. It was so good, too good actually! I’m trying my best to not buy another. I have no self control when it comes to this pie. I love it!!!

I was very excited to find a key lime pie at Sam's... but it was missing the lime part of key lime, sadly. It ate more like a cheesecake than any kind of pie.