There was barely any lime flavor in this pie. I served it at a family gathering. No one liked it. It tasted very artificial. No one could figure out waht the topping was made of, it had a weird texture.

The Key lime portion of the pie was very good, but the white "whipped cream" around the edges is more like frosting and the texture wasn't good, kind of greasy, no flavor. It would be better if it were lighter. We scrapped it off.

The member's Mark key lime pie I bought from Sam's I was very excited because I had seen some reviews talking about it was so good. Not true it was terrible I will never ever buy another key lime from Sam's club. It was a total waste of money

This key lime pie is out of this world GOOD. Not too sweet but, the real winner that brings everything together is the buttery graham cracker crust! Highly recommend

This is hands down the best store bought brand keylime pie. It's also priced great and there's enough to feed your whole family.its also my go to to take to potlucks and gatherings.

There was too much sweetener in the whip cream and pie filling to enjoy. Most desserts don’t last long in our household. The pie stayed for more than a week. Pass on this.

I ate the whole pie. It was so good, too good actually! I’m trying my best to not buy another. I have no self control when it comes to this pie. I love it!!!

Texture was smooth and silky, however it lacked the taste of key lime. After having one small slice I returned the pie. Thanks for Sam’s great return policy.

Decently priced and gets the job done, though is overtly sweet and lacking in lime flavor. If you're desperate to get something for others it'll likely keep them at bay.

Almost returned this pie. My husband and I agreed the taste lacked key lime, the crust and cream were lackluster and it generally was well below average. We will not purchase it again.