Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark 10" Key Lime Pie, 41 oz. for
Member's Mark 10" Key Lime Pie, 41 oz.
4.6 out of 5 stars
stars6,058 ratings1,461 reviews
  1. 5 stars82% (4,943)
  2. 4 stars8% (497)
  3. 3 stars5% (285)
  4. 2 stars2% (135)
  5. 1 star3% (198)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 11-20 of 1,461 reviews
Dec 26, 2025
JCP
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Key Lime Pie

The pie was good enough for a Sam's Club bakery but they need to adhere to the original recipe. The lemony taste was missing, and the coloring was not a true Key Lime Pie.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Mar 24, 2026
Candid Critic
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Our favorite

This is hands down the best store bought brand keylime pie. It's also priced great and there's enough to feed your whole family.its also my go to to take to potlucks and gatherings.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Jul 10, 2025
Mary
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Saved the day.

I needed to take a dessert to a group function but wasn't feeling up to baking. Instead I purchased this pie along with fresh raspberries. I made raspberry sauce. Served this keylime pie with the sauce and some fresh fresh berries. It was a hit. Thanks for offer this delicious dessert.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Jul 22, 2025
DH
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Best store bought Key Lime!

One of the best pre-made key lime pies I've ever bought. Not overly sweet and not bitter. Creamy texture - not as creamy as some restaurant-made pies I've had, but very good for a store bought. Better than the frozen key lime pies I've purchased.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Jun 12, 2025
CD
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Artificial flavor

The flavor of this pie was very artificial to the point that it tasted like plastic. I bought these pies a few years ago but then they were not available for a long time. Sam's made a big deal that the Key Lime pie was back, so I gave it try. Not only was the flavor off but the crust was a little soggy to the point that I could not serve up a slice without it just falling apart. I'm guessing they found another supplier. My wife and I both had the same comments so I returned the remaining 3/4 of the pie for a refund.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Jul 28, 2025
Jadwiga
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Glad for purchase

My husband did a taste test in the store and loved it. Due to my citrus allergy he didn't want to purchase it, but he couldn't get it out of his mind. Bakery employee said that it froze well. He was glad that we bought it. Said that it did freeze well tasting just as fresh as when first got it.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Apr 30, 2026
Charlie
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Key Lime Pie

There was no key lime or any lime flavor in the entire pie, wasted money

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
May 3, 2026
JJDfields
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

The best key Lime Pie ever!

This was the best pie I’ve had in a long time. Very good flavor and there was nothing left on pan.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
Apr 28, 2026
Debbie E
2 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Disappointing !

This did not meet my expectations . The lime flavor was barely recognizable. The whip cream tasted very artificial

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147
May 10, 2026
Becky L
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Love the key lime pie

This key lime pie is amazing. For the price, this is hands down the best way to indulge in this heavenly dessert.

Helpful?1J88V2WEAW5Z13596852147