Price is excellent. Taste is good, but needs a little more lime juice. The crust is very good. The whipping cream looks good, BUT, WHOA... does not taste like a food product. Seriously, we had to scrape it off. This cannot be good for you. I suppose they use this whipped topping because it looks good and will last. Yeah... probably retains its shape for a year or more. Guess you can tell we didn't care for the topping.

This key lime pie is restaurant quality. The filling is spot-on regarding the balance of tart and sweetness and the whip cream toping is complementary and balanced. The graham cracker crust is also very nicely done with the right amount of crumble and texture. I have not found a better tasting pie at any specialty bakery.

The crust & filling are good, but the whipped topping wasn't my favorite. Seemed stale tasting almost.

One of our favorite desserts and the one my family requests when they know we are shopping there! The flavor and quality are always consistant.

This is the best Key Lime Pie I have ever eaten. The pie is big enough to feed 8 people (or more depending on the size of your slices). Just beware no matter what size you cut for yourself you are going to be wanting more!

This pie was a chance taken the first try- now it is a regular purchase since we fell in love. Only $9 less than a slightly larger pie at the big C. I laughed cause I knew it couldn't be my Sam's pie!!!

The key lime part of the pie and the crust was good, however the “whipped cream” on top tasted more like chemicals than cream. It doesn't even dissolve in water in the sink! It's more like Twinkie filling, not a fan.

The pie was just OK. However, I'm guessing you just have to be Keylime type of person. Was the least popular dessert of the night. I would definitely choose other Sam's pies over this.

Delicious! Perfect amount of tartness and sweetness. The whipped cream is also creamy and delicious.

I ate the whole pie. It was so good, too good actually! I’m trying my best to not buy another. I have no self control when it comes to this pie. I love it!!!