The pie filling has that great tart key lime flavor, but the creamy bits on top have an odd consistency and not much taste. It would be better to just have the filling and no creamy bits.

First, the price is excellent considering how huge this pie is. Very creamy, and the crust delicious. It could use a bit more key lime flavor, however, if you don't like a strong taste, then this pie flavor will be perfect for you!

This is one of the most delicious pies, I have ever had that is store bought. My family & friends always think I made it. I tell them no, this came from Sam’s. Thanks for sharing this great dessert with us. Keep up the great work!!!!!!

This Key Lime pie was delicious. Very fresh and everyone loved it. I am hooked. Price was reasonable. We picked up one and n ext trip we got two. Will buy again.

Wow!! I had this at someone else’s house as a dessert. Loved it and now we buy it for a dessert option for company. It’s a thick pie with the perfect amount of lime flavoring!

My first time ever having Keylime pie was in Florida amazing in the last 15 years Sams Club the Keylime pie is the only other one that I would put second to Florida

My son-in-law loves key lime pie. I've bought this particular pie once for a family dinner and the raves from him earned it a regular place on our summer table. Hail to the pastry chef.

This pie is absolutely creamy and delicious at a good price! My family loved it. It's dangerously good. Like I want it all the time but I'm on low carb diet and can only have this occasionally. It's divine.

I didn't like it. The crust was not crunchy. It was chewy. The whip cream frosting wasn't whip cream something else tasted processed not freshly made.

I spend winters in the Keys, so I know good key lime pie. Sam’s pie is one of my favorites. Great graham cracker crust, tart key lime, and a super sweet topping that is not just whipped cream.