Love the price, noticed this purchase had less key lime taste and was a paler green color. Stilled enjoyed tge pie, but not as good as previous (2) pies i have bought. Noticeable difference.

First, the price is excellent considering how huge this pie is. Very creamy, and the crust delicious. It could use a bit more key lime flavor, however, if you don't like a strong taste, then this pie flavor will be perfect for you!

The Member's Mark Key Lime Pie taste GREAT! Reminds me of when Red Lobster was exclusive but not anymore. I high recommend Sam's Club Key Lime Pie for anytime. It's light tangy key lime flavor is FANTASTIC!

My first time ever having Keylime pie was in Florida amazing in the last 15 years Sams Club the Keylime pie is the only other one that I would put second to Florida

The BEST Key Lime pie, seriously better than most of the places in FL - creamy, cheesecake like center, a whipped frosting (whipped cream but make it sweeter) with a crumbled gram cracker crust. Its truly perfection

Is Keyla pie is awesome. I don’t know what type of whip cream that is on top but it is just a beautiful pie. You won’t go wrong with. It is the best Keylime cheesecake pie I’ve had altogether.

Excellent keylime flavor..way better than the other big club. The crust could be better though. The crust from the other big club w this keylime filling would make this pie phenomenal!

I think shrinkflation may have recently caused this pie to get much smaller. But it used to be good tasting and a good value. Probably still is good tasting!

This pie was so beautiful that I wanted to cut into it immediately but couldn't because it was for a family gathering. It was so wonderful, creamy and taste delicious!

This pie was really good but a little too creamy for my experience with key lime pies I prefer a more custard or lime curd flavor with more lime punch