The pie was so fresh and delicious

One of our favorite for a sweat treat. I wish they had them year-round!

Not enough lime flavor or tartness

Key lime pie is smaller and the price increased. Sometimes the topping is horrible tasting. I've actually given it up. Too bad. I was a regular buyer. Not anymore.

I have been a huge fan of these pies for quite a while. However, I purchased one on September 22 at the Flagstaff store and it was waaaay too sweet. The lime was barely noticeable. Did you change your recipe? If so, please return to the former one as it was the best ever!

Delicious!! I would serve this with company! :) Graham cracker crust is generous and holds together nicely. Filling is tart and really creamy. It is definitely on par with Publix’s wildly popular key lime pie. $10 is a great price as well! Sam’s Club for the win!!🎉

This Key lime pie is delicious! I've bought it several times now,& it's always so good! Just buy the pie!

This pie is SO delicious! It’s great for serving to company or if it’s just a special treat time at home. Give it a try. You won’t be disappointed.

We wanted to love this pie but it wasn't very good. It did not really taste like key lime. Pretty dissapointed that most of it ended up in the trash.

Delicious crust with right amount of texture & taste, filling is perfectly tart & sweet. I suggest removing the whipped cream & adding fresh