DELICIOUSLY RICH

Amazing

I was so excited to try this key lime pie when I saw it, especially knowing how good Sam Club's pumpkin pie is. I was oh, so, sorely disappointed! This is not any kind of key lime pie I have ever tasted. It is nothing but chemical flavor. I can't recommend this to anyone since it literally tastes like poison.

really good

Delicious

Best key lime pie ever!

Way too sweet. This is the kind of sweet that hurts your teeth when you take a bite which doesn't happen to me with other sweets. It's awful. Even my husband, without prompting him, said it was too sweet and he loves sweets. If i could get my money back i would. Sorry Sam's.

Very delicious

I bought this pie for my son’s birthday and all of us at the party agreed it had a very offputting flavor. Almost a fishy taste. Sadly, the remainder of this pie went in the garbage. I probably won’t buy another cold pie from Sams Club again. Very disappointing.

I have been seeing this pie for yrs and finally ordered one for a family gathering. In the Pickup. Surprise - it is not as big as they used to be. But the price isn't lower. Thinking this will not be big enough to feed the whole family. The old one looked huge. Sam's, you are starting to give your customers grocery store sized packages, then what is the point of my membership???