As good as our favorite key lime pie in the Keys. We usually would make a stop in Islamorada where for the price of this pie, we could get a mini pie. This one is incredible!

Key lime pie is smaller and the price increased. Sometimes the topping is horrible tasting. I've actually given it up. Too bad. I was a regular buyer. Not anymore.

Delicious!!!! I usually don't like to buy store bought desserts because I prefer to make them myself but this one is the best!!! Restaurant style !! Filling is rich and creamy!

We are an egg-free household, so good desserts are a bit harder to come by. My husband claims to not be a fan of citrus anything, but we have nearly eaten this entire pie in three days and he loves it. Please make one in a lemon flavor!!

Honestly, the best key lime pie I have had. Not to sweet or tart, well balanced. I will be honest, I'm not a huge crust person. But this crust is absolutely delicious. I have bought this pie everytime I make a trip to Sam's.

Dislike the entire pie. The white whipped topping tastes horrible. To thick and gunky. The creamy lime filling has a very thick texture. This pies is not all light and creamy. Will not purchase again.

Your key lime pie was so indescribably delicious! It was better than any homemade key lime pie’s I’ve ever had. The graham cracker crust was amazing & flavorful! It was a great price too! I definitely would buy it again for my next family get together!

I've read that these pies were larger in the past but I still find this a good value. Love these pies. They last a long time (a small piece goes a long way.) I'm not into tart or bitter, so I find the lime "bite" to be well balanced. You may be disappointed if you like lime pie so strong that it puckers up your lips.

This was an absolute disappointment of a key lime pie. It was completely tasteless and the texture and mouthfeel was horrible. I bought it to share with my mom and dad (dad is 92 and he lives for pies) and they both did not like it and sent the rest home with me.

I have been a huge fan of these pies for quite a while. However, I purchased one on September 22 at the Flagstaff store and it was waaaay too sweet. The lime was barely noticeable. Did you change your recipe? If so, please return to the former one as it was the best ever!