Too much crust, which was too oily. Real whipped cream would have been better than the thick whipped topping. Lime filling was just ok. Overall, not worth it.

Go back to the old recipe. It’s overly sweet and not tart. The crust tastes like ginger snap cookies, instead of graham crackers, and way too crumbly.

I really wanted to like this pie but, no lime taste at all. Just a sweet pie with quality crust. Have had many a key lime pie, so simple to add more lime flavor initially but no way to add flavor after the fact.

Wonderful pie I can't believe how good this is it taste like homemade pie it's like a meringue with soft filling and heavy whipping cream with a smooth soft hint of sugared crust! Please carry all the time.

It was bad enough that the chocolate pie recipe changed last fall, but now the key lime pie is a spring disaster, too. It's a shame. We used to buy a pie every week.

I thought they would use less butter and oil. This pie has a hint of lime flavor, but mostly it tastes unhealthy and high in cholesterol. Choosing one from Safeway would be a better option than this.

Not that good... the crust was way to crumbly and thick. The Key lime was a bit gritty and the whipped cream was just ok. Would not buy this every again!

Not enough key lime juice. Just a sweet taste with and edge of bitterness. The “whipped topping” is not for human consumption. Buy their apple pie instead!

Nothing about this is key lime pie. Taste like chemicals without even a hint of lime. Even the topping taste like chemical. Doesn't anyone at Sam's even try this?

Filling and crust were good, whipped topping is a high negative. The sample given out had real whipped cream. Then the ‘bait and switch’ happened. The product had, what I call, plastic whipped something else nasty; once scraped off the pie was good!