I have been a huge fan of these pies for quite a while. However, I purchased one on September 22 at the Flagstaff store and it was waaaay too sweet. The lime was barely noticeable. Did you change your recipe? If so, please return to the former one as it was the best ever!

The MM key lime pie is delicious! It has the perfect balance of sweet and tart and the key lime zing is on the money. The texture is smooth and the crust has just enough crunch (not soggy at all). Also the amount of whipped topping is just right. It's a nice size for a pot luck, family dinner, or just to have on hand to enjoy on a hot summer evening. And you cannot beat the price for $10.

I've read that these pies were larger in the past but I still find this a good value. Love these pies. They last a long time (a small piece goes a long way.) I'm not into tart or bitter, so I find the lime "bite" to be well balanced. You may be disappointed if you like lime pie so strong that it puckers up your lips.

My husband had tasted this at guy's night playing cards and thought it was great. I should add he does not like Key Lime Pie. It is seasonal at Sam's around us so I had to wait until Spring to get one. Absolutely loved it and I am picky about my Key Lime Pie's (you could ditch the whipped cream though). I would and have recommended this pie.

This pie wasn’t what I expected. It was too soft which made it difficult to slice. I couldn’t get a single slice without it falling apart. The taste wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t great. This is the first and the last time I will ever get this pie. Their other pies and cakes are way better.

This was an absolute disappointment of a key lime pie. It was completely tasteless and the texture and mouthfeel was horrible. I bought it to share with my mom and dad (dad is 92 and he lives for pies) and they both did not like it and sent the rest home with me.

Sadly will be returning as the best by date was past before the pie was served. This was a curbside pickup. I would have most certainly noticed the date if I had chosen the pie myself. These are really delicious pies normally but I definitely want it within date and to be fresh upon serving. This has not been a normal experience for me when shopping at Sams club or curbside pickups. Disappointed I wasn’t able to serve this when planned I know they will make it right just hate the inconvenience of returning it.

We have been buying this pie for years! Sometimes it's our only reason for going to Sam's Club. We've bought it for special occasions and days when we just want a treat! You can't beat the value. The crust and filling are amazing. The only thing I would change is the whipped topping. It's definitely not my favorite, but I just scrape it off.

YUM! Best served just short of frozen, for our tastes, it's not like grandma used to make, which is just fine, as I think the prep/presentation superior to grandma's. It's not like the 'real' thing, however, as it's not nearly as tart as one you'd get from the local bakery in Key West or even Miami. But for a large party, or a dinner gathering, it does the job admirably.

I always liked key lime pie, but the flavor always seemed fake. There was a sale on this one and I decided to give it a try. It is the best key lime pie I had in Paducah. It tastes just right. It is not super sweet and you can tell it was truly made with key lime pie. I would prefer less whipped cream, but it is not a bad combination.