Filling and crust were good, whipped topping is a high negative. The sample given out had real whipped cream. Then the ‘bait and switch’ happened. The product had, what I call, plastic whipped something else nasty; once scraped off the pie was good!

Not enough key lime juice. Just a sweet taste with and edge of bitterness. The “whipped topping” is not for human consumption. Buy their apple pie instead!

Key lime pie is smaller and the price increased. Sometimes the topping is horrible tasting. I've actually given it up. Too bad. I was a regular buyer. Not anymore.

Not that good... the crust was way to crumbly and thick. The Key lime was a bit gritty and the whipped cream was just ok. Would not buy this every again!

I have been a huge fan of these pies for quite a while. However, I purchased one on September 22 at the Flagstaff store and it was waaaay too sweet. The lime was barely noticeable. Did you change your recipe? If so, please return to the former one as it was the best ever!

Your key lime pie was so indescribably delicious! It was better than any homemade key lime pie’s I’ve ever had. The graham cracker crust was amazing & flavorful! It was a great price too! I definitely would buy it again for my next family get together!

We had a taste for a Key Lime pie but the grocery store charges a lot for a much smaller one. We decided to try Sam's key lime. It's light and delicious tasting. Since there's only two of us, we froze most of it into 2 slices per container. We take them out of the freezer and thaw them out here and there so that can enjoy them whenever we want.

We have been buying this pie for years! Sometimes it's our only reason for going to Sam's Club. We've bought it for special occasions and days when we just want a treat! You can't beat the value. The crust and filling are amazing. The only thing I would change is the whipped topping. It's definitely not my favorite, but I just scrape it off.

Sadly will be returning as the best by date was past before the pie was served. This was a curbside pickup. I would have most certainly noticed the date if I had chosen the pie myself. These are really delicious pies normally but I definitely want it within date and to be fresh upon serving. This has not been a normal experience for me when shopping at Sams club or curbside pickups. Disappointed I wasn’t able to serve this when planned I know they will make it right just hate the inconvenience of returning it.

This pie wasn’t what I expected. It was too soft which made it difficult to slice. I couldn’t get a single slice without it falling apart. The taste wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t great. This is the first and the last time I will ever get this pie. Their other pies and cakes are way better.