Recently bought this spread because it’s cheaper than butter and remember it actually tasting like butter when we regularly bought it years ago. Something has definitely changed with its recipe because the flavor now is nothing like real butter. I used it on pancakes and it had a sour taste and thick consistency to it. I will pay the extra couple dollars for actual butter, thank you.

We are extremely disappointed in the new recipe for your margarine. It does not have the same flavor and has no cream. It is predominantly soy and strange oils. Soy is fattening! Also the containers are now smaller. We are tired of 15 Oz. Compared to 16oz. We are searching for a new margarine again.

I have been purchasing "I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!" for about a couple of years now. It tastes just like real butter and my family prefers it over the real butter. Its easy for quick snack as it does not become solid while in refrigerator. I simply love this product. Thank you so much.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I absolutely love I Can't Believe It's Not Butter spread. I use it on toast, bagels, pasta and all cooking recipes. The taste is really yummy. In fact, my husband prefers to let his toast cool down before he spreads it on so that it doesn't melt so much because he loves the taste.

We've been using your product for many years, but not any longer. My wife is a dietician and an outstanding cook. She is horrified that you took an excellent product and changed the formulation so she can no longer cook with it. Any chef knows that appearance and texture are important along with taste. You've managed to degrade all three in one try. You really need to change back again.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I recently picked up a big tub of CBINB. I cooked like normal and used it in place of butter. My family which includes children and my elderly mom couldn't tell any difference. That alone will make me change.

How can this be called original? It has gone from Fresh butter taste to 100% taste...what does that even mean? First ingredient water....makes toast soggy.....no longer has sweet cream buttermilk (there goes the buttery taste)....can't be frozen....i could go on and on....bottom line.....I was a big buyer of the Original original, but will not buy the new original ....it is a waste of money...New simple recipe = terrible taste. Gave 1 star rating because it wouldn't let me give no stars.

Grease trap! For so many years this was the “healthy” butter but the saturated fat would disagree. I went through a phase on whatever diet where I tried to like this thinking it was healthier but it might as well be Country Crocker. It’s overly flavored to taste like butter and be careful with it if you’re watching sodium.

Have always used this spread but they have changed this ingredients and it now taste horrible. New spread now has a chemical smell and taste when you cook with it. At first thought it was just me until I made a grill cheese sandwich for my wife and she could not eat it because she said it taste bad. I will never buy this spread again unless they go back to the former ingredients.

I have been a loyal customer for many years. When I bought the new rectangular tub the other day...I simply thought they had just changed the packaging. I was very unhappy to find out they actually changed the formula as well. No one in the house likes this new formula. GO BACK TO THE ORIGINAL FLAVOR NOW!