It is horrible, bland and mashed! When will anyone in the market make a decent potato salad, we have to make it from scratch at home! The other potato salad you carry is as bad but with way to much add ins!

This potato salad is way too sweet and well just not southern potato salad like I have always had. It's better than the loaded potato salad but still misses the mark. Texture of potatoes was better than many.

Tastes homemade and I have never ever purchased a store potato salad that is any good at all! Thanks for all the good reviews that prompted me to buy this. I don’t have to make potato salad any more. Few tweets here and there any it’s great!!

This is the most 'home made' tasting commercial potato salad I've ever tried! It's excellent. The only issue is that recently it has been very difficult to find in my club.

I really wish you would bring back the southern style mustard potato salad that you use to carry. The loaded style is really bad, and this is not much better.

This is the first time we have purchased Potato Salad from a store that was as good as home made salad. This Southern Style is wonderful. THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!!!

I used to buy this potato salad at almost every trip to Sam's. A while back it changed in flavor and became overly creamy. No longer worth buying as I was throwing away most of a carton.

I wouldn’t serve this to a pack of wild dogs. The mayo they use is the consistency of whipped cream and there was wayyyyy too much sugar in this recipe overall. I threw the whole tub away after a small serving 🤮

What happened? We used to love it but the last 2 packages were mostly sauce and limited potatoes! Tried to scoop it out and it just "melted" on the plate.

I bought this after reading all the great reviews, but I was very disappointed. I like my potato salad a bit sweet & tangy, but this is just flat and so sweet it's like dessert. You can't beat the price, but it was just too sweet for my taste.