I really wish Sam's had just good old-fashioned potato salad! This is too sweet and the other is loaded with bacon. Not everyone loves bacon, and the sour cream is too thick.

This is so much better than other store-bought tater salads. The potatoes are in bite-size chunks and not all mayonaissey. Definitely an improvement over what I've tried to make at home. Still tastes great a week after opening it.

Entirely TOO sweet. We may like our sweet tea but sweet potato salad is going too far. Only buy this if you like super sweet salads. I will be returning. Thank goodness I tasted before taking to family function.

Pretty good potato salad. I used it for a group event and everyone seemed to like it; I didn't have much left over afterwards. Slightly sweet, slightly oniony in flavor. The little kids liked it as well as the adults.

Great potato salad that you csn mKe even better if uou have the time to add-in things like chopped celery or boiled eggs, celery seed, pimento, vaious seasonings, etc. Good to eat at home, church dinners, bring to parties, etc.

I have purchased members mark potato salad for years. Always looked forward to it. This batch was under cooked. Potatoes were almost raw. Very disappointed.

This potato salad is so good, and the price can't be best. It is not worth making homemade when you can buy this at such a great value. It is perfect for a cookout or BBQ. Highly recommended!

Omg -this is the best store brought salad I have ever had. Generally I add some additional stuff like eggs, onions, etc - well although I still added those things; the salad really needed nothing but mustard. This is my go to from now on

One of the best store bought potato salads I've had. Feed a family of 9 with plenty left for second servings. I made the mistake of getting two...that was way too much.

Great basic mustard based potato salad. Can eat it straight from the container, but I typically add a few more spices to personalize and enhance the dish. It's always a hit at our family bbqs.