Absolutely delicious classic mustard potato salad with crisp veggies and a creamy dressing! Would buy this over Cub any day!

I really wish Sam's had just good old-fashioned potato salad! This is too sweet and the other is loaded with bacon. Not everyone loves bacon, and the sour cream is too thick.

Omg -this is the best store brought salad I have ever had. Generally I add some additional stuff like eggs, onions, etc - well although I still added those things; the salad really needed nothing but mustard. This is my go to from now on

I tried this for the first time a while back and it was DELICIOUS but the potatoes was hard! I did a review and finally decided to try it again and it’s PERFECT!! I still highly recommend this, it tastes like my Grandmother made it!!

I have purchased members mark potato salad for years. Always looked forward to it. This batch was under cooked. Potatoes were almost raw. Very disappointed.

Served this at a family get-together and everyone loved it. So much so that I ran out! Many asked where I purchased this because they wanted to buy more for home.

Pretty good potato salad. I used it for a group event and everyone seemed to like it; I didn't have much left over afterwards. Slightly sweet, slightly oniony in flavor. The little kids liked it as well as the adults.

Sam’s club use to sell the potato salad and then it went away for a couple of months, when it came back it was not the same. This potato salad was really good but now it’s awful. Don’t waste your money

We tried this one time and it was not edible for us, the St. Clair was 100% better and we use to buy it regularly but will never buy the substitute again. We tossed the container after trying to eat it a couple of times!

Thus potato salad was terrible. I will never buy this again. I don’t know why Sam’s change companies. The other one was much better. I wasted my money. Was very disappointed. It was to call thick and creamy!!!!