way way too sweet. almost to the point of it being a dessert salad which just does not work for potato salad. the potato salad itself looks amazing. I was so excited to find it and try it and it looks fabulous until you put it in your mouth. and it's so sweet it's nauseating. I'm from the south my family's from the South Kentucky and we make southern style all the time but this flat out has a ton of sugar in it. really do not understand all the rave reviews. if you like really sweet potato salad this is your go-to. potato salad should have a little bit of sweet but nothing like this it was way sweeter than any coleslaw I've ever tasted. and coleslaws on the sweet side

My husband LOVES this (and so do I) potato salad. For us this style is perfect - consistent flavor, just he right amount of mayo and other ingredients. Not too thick and sticky with just the right amount of creaminess and body. Very good flavor. If you prefer a more runny, mustardy potato salad this is not for you.

The Member’s Mark potato salad is awful. The potatoes are hard and the taste cannot compare to the St. Claire potato salad. I realize the company is making it for Sam’s, but St. Claire certainly didn’t do Sam’s any justice in making this under the Member’s Mark name. They set Sam’s up for failure with this product. I highly recommend Sam’s go back to purchasing the St. Claire’s brand. I will NOT purchase the Member’s Mark potato salad again.

My husband and I struggle with the exact timing for boiling the potatoes causing mash potato salad. Well we decided to try Sams Club potato salad and dress it up with additional ingredients. Oh my! Best potato salad ever!!! We will definitely purchase again. This southern style potato salad will be a go to purchase for all family events moving forward.

I tried this product the beginning of September because I was having an event at the end of the month. I was very pleased with the taste and texture of the potato salad. I purchased 5 tunes for my event and everything had changed. It was horrible. I looked at it and could see the difference. I was telling everyone about how good the potato salad was but not anymore. I don't recommend at all. You had a good product and there was no reason to change it.

This was always my favorite prepared potato salad, but the one I bought yesterday was terrible. The potatoes were almost raw and the sauce was very soupy and not as flavorful as usual. Very disappointed in one of my favorite Sam's Club items that I always recommended.

I couldn’t have made potato salad myself any better than this!

The potato salad was good as usual

Very good quality and flavor

Tastes like Homemade Potato salad My Mom use to make