Members Mark Southern Potato Salad tastes very close to homemade. I noticed the recipe changed over the last year. Mayo tastes fluffier but the overall taste did not change. I would certainly recommend this product for your summer time cookouts and picnics. Simply garnish the product with your favorite items and you'll be sure to fool many into thinking Members Mark is "homemade. "

The only good thing is the price. If you can buy some other brand (GFS or Meijer- good but not consistent) and possibly spread out the sweetness, it may be worth a try. But maybe not. The trouble with the two recommended is the price. Last summer, GFS was $6.50 /3 lbs; Meijer will occasionally have it on sale, but not as often). its gotten ridiculous. We are well past Covid and these companies (and many others) keep raising the price. Most have millions plus assets. You decide. I'm not an economist. With all the recipes out there the quality could be much better. I know it's made in large amounts and packed, but c'mon.

I loved this potato salad and so did my whole family. It’s great with roasted chicken and barbecue ribs! Usually store bought potato salad will sit in the fridge afterward but not this one! Our family devoured it! Will buy again soon. Please don’t stop making it!

Really delicious, I add either dill or tarragon to mine at home before eating it. I don’t have cook, peel and chop now to get a delicious, Say “Yum” to a super potato salad. It’s not too vinegary, sweet, eggy, mustardy or with too much mayonnaise, ***It’s just right if Goldi Locks would have said if she had been given this to her by the Three Bears.

If you hate sour potato salad, don't buy this! It tastes like they dumped a half gallon of dill pickle juice in it. I could hardly eat it. Even my husband who likes sour stuff more than me said it was almost too sour for him. I miss the mayonnaise-based potato salad Sam's used to carry--can't get it anymore at my store.

We've bought this Potato salad numerous times and it has never disappointed us !!! It's a little too sweet for me but I find myself sneaking into the fridge for a spoonful lol. We have never hesitated to serve St.Clair's to anybody that comes over and wish we could take all the credit,well we do because we bought it LOL

I was always loyal to Publix's Southern Style Potato Salad until I discovered this at Sam's. Honestly, I still prefer the taste of Publix's but am tired of not enough potatoes and too much relish and eggs. Sam's' would be perfect if it didn't have that sweet taste.

I have special dietary needs and have a hard time finding many things that I can eat without getting sick. I recently discovered this potato salad and it is LIFE CHANGING. I am ashamed to say I ate almost the entire 5 lbs in 2 weeks. This potato salad is great with any other foods or even just by itself as a meal.

Disgustingly sweet! I love sweet foods, including potato salad (I'm not a fan of salty mustard potato salad) but the amount of sugar in this is so bad it tastes like they dumped a 5lb bag of sugar in the container. My family could not eat it, even when we added some salt and mustard to balance the sweetness -there was just too much sugar in it. Please do better Sam's Club and cut the sugar in this by half, or label it Potato Pudding. We returned for a refund.

This new southern potato salad is horrible too sweet and there aren't enough ingredients in my pantry to fix it.. I bought it to take to 4th of July bbq pot luck I had to throw it out and I hate to waste money!!! PLEASE BRING BACK THE LOADED BAKED POTATO SALAD.. IT WAS DELICIOUS