I used to buy this potato salad at almost every trip to Sam's. A while back it changed in flavor and became overly creamy. No longer worth buying as I was throwing away most of a carton.

I bought this after reading all the great reviews, but I was very disappointed. I like my potato salad a bit sweet & tangy, but this is just flat and so sweet it's like dessert. You can't beat the price, but it was just too sweet for my taste.

Not sure how this got over 4 stars!! It’s way too sweet. It’s like a mouthful of sugar. I had to doctor it up by adding mayo, sour cream and mustard. Anything to tone down the sweetness.

This is the first time we have purchased Potato Salad from a store that was as good as home made salad. This Southern Style is wonderful. THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!!!

Sorry, but this was terrible. It's not just the amount of sweet, it's a texture thing also. It's sort of gooey. Will never buy again, does not taste like potatoes.

What happened? We used to love it but the last 2 packages were mostly sauce and limited potatoes! Tried to scoop it out and it just "melted" on the plate.

A friend brought this to a party we had Saturday. I don't care for chopped-up eggs in my potato salad so I was happy to see that this did not contain any. The texture is good - the potatoes are not mushy - they are done but firm. This potato salad really tastes like it was made from scratch - I was surprised to find out that it wasn't. This will be a welcome addition for when I don't want to take the time to make my own.

I loved this potato salad and so did my whole family. It’s great with roasted chicken and barbecue ribs! Usually store bought potato salad will sit in the fridge afterward but not this one! Our family devoured it! Will buy again soon. Please don’t stop making it!

I was always loyal to Publix's Southern Style Potato Salad until I discovered this at Sam's. Honestly, I still prefer the taste of Publix's but am tired of not enough potatoes and too much relish and eggs. Sam's' would be perfect if it didn't have that sweet taste.

I have special dietary needs and have a hard time finding many things that I can eat without getting sick. I recently discovered this potato salad and it is LIFE CHANGING. I am ashamed to say I ate almost the entire 5 lbs in 2 weeks. This potato salad is great with any other foods or even just by itself as a meal.