I was hosting a baby shower with only 10 days to prepare. I ordered a yellow frosted cake to add silk flowers to it for decoration. Mom to be’s nursery colors are not in available choices. Cake was just as I wanted and the silk wildflowers looked lovely against the yellow frosting! It tasted great too!

This 1/2 sheet cake is very tasty. Choice of white or dark cake and buttercream or whipped topping. Nice decorating, message etc. Included. We were very happy with everything about it, especially the price. Literally half of what Hy-Vee charges for a not nearly as good cake of same size.

The cake tastes good but the icing was not applied well. You could see the crumb coat. Icing was uneven across the cake. Lettering was not uniform and icing colors didn’t really match well. I added sprinkles to cover the bare spots. Probably will not order again.

I ordered a custom birthday cake as designed on the website for a family member. I was really concerned as to how the cake would look once I picked it up because I ordered online. I must say I was very pleased with how it was designed when I picked it up and with the fresh, moist taste. All of my family were pleased as well. Also, the price was affordable for the half sheet size. I will definitely order another cake.

I ordered a whipped cream frosting and marble cake a week before pickup. Unfortunately, on the day of pickup I got a call from Sam’s Club saying they didn’t have whipped cream frosting and marble cake. So I had to change my order to Whipped cream frosting and white cake. Sam’s did have the new cake ready for pickup on time and the cake was tasty. So I’m giving them a four star rating.

The colors on the cake nor the design was not as ordered. When brought to the attention of a bakery worker they said there was nothing they could do. The birthday party was the same day so we had no option other than to purchase. If we had another option we would not have purchased.

The sheet cakes I have purchase from Sam’s are very good and reasonably priced. I have been shopping with Sam’s for more than 10 years. As of this year 2025 I will no longer shop there because of their stand against DEI. I will also not renew my membership.

The cake itself is great. Only being able to order online is horrible. The amount of customization is drastically reduced online compared to ordering in store. My wife ordered the cake and right after she placed the order she saw that she placed it for the wrong date. There was no way to edit the date or even cancel the order online. I had to go into the store to have them change the date which is ridiculous.

I was SO impressed with the appearance of this cake! I could not have been more happier. This cake was going to an adult day care agency. That had cared for my mother-in-law for approximately six years or more. They deserved to have the perfect cake. Fortunately, Sam’s Club did NOT fall short! I would DEFINITELY order this cake again. Unfortunately, I didn’t get the opportunity to taste the cake. But I’m sure it was just as good as the appearance.

Cake was good but not ready on time. I was there on time. Came back an hour later then 2 1/2 hours later. Still not ready. The person I talked to had no sympathy or anything & was actually pretty rude. I live in a different town and thankfully the party was the next day so I had to go back the next morning to pick it up. The cake itself was good and it was decorated ok. & the price was very good other than the gas to go back.