After not having their beer battered cod fillets for a while, we were happy to see them available again. Unfortunately, their "new formulation" is a total disappointment and doesn't measure up to the previous product. The taste is very bland and had to be slathered with tartar sauce to be decent. Plus there was an odd, unpleasant taste that was difficult to describe until I saw another reviewer mention that it contains aluminum. That has to be the odd taste. Additionally, I am not happy that the package says it is "Processed in the USA" intentionally avoiding mentioning the source of the ingredients. We deserve to know where our food originated. I will not knowingly consume any food items from China, and I suspect that is where most of the ingredients were acquired. We will be purchasing beer battered cod fillets elsewhere from now on.

The directions basically have us cook these small fish pieces into more than half the size they started. It turns the breading too dark of brown, the fish turns dry, and extremely overcooked. The fish itself is without flavor, but the breading is seasoned ok. I won't purchase this again.

I used an air fryer and exactly followed the directions on the box. They turned out unpleasantly mushy. On the flavor side, they didn’t taste too fishy so that’s a plus. I also like that they are wild-caught, if that’s actually true. One piece out of the five I made was inedible because it had hard strands of what seemed to be gristle throughout. I’ll try again and use an oven next time, but only because I hate to waste food. Will not be buying again.

These little cod filets are great in the air fryer. They have just the right amount of crispness without being too oily. I have only had with rice and tartar sauce, but I bet they would be good as a fish sandwich. You would need at least 2 filets to make the sandwich and they are a little smaller.

this was the worst breaded fish ( cod or otherwise) that I've ever had, and I am 74 y/o so that says something. couldn't even chew it, and I have good teeth. it wasn't cut across the grain. was long pieces of tough ( which means refrozen after the first thaw) cod fish. gave it to our dog. will be returning the rest. what a waste of time %26 electricity to bake it. i now have indigestion. sad.

I couldn't get the frozen cod fillets that I wanted so thought I would try this. Should have kept my money. Doesn't taste like cod, only thing I taste is the nasty breading. Even the breading is bad. If you really like cod don't waste your money on this.

Honestly, we gave this product a shot...but it is not quality "Cod Fillets". Why is it that customers can't find premium Fish items for Home, like the Fish that Culver's serves? It certainly isn't of Members Mark quality. Its worth a refund, especially for what it costs.

Cod fillets are mushy and not very good. I air fried as instructed on the box and mushy fish was the result. I tired again at 400 for 15 minutes. Crispy but still mushy inside. Compare these to the “Everything Cod Fillets” that used to be in club, those were fantastic and great quality. Bring those back!!!!'

Does not disappoint. real fish filet, NOT pieces and parts. If you like beer battered cod, this is delicious in an airfryer. Just needs a few more minutes then stated to bring it up to temp. Add french fries and coleslaw and you can get 5-6 meals for the price of one restaurant fish and chips.

I bought a Bella Pro Airfryer Oven back in 2022 for about $80, and I always use it to cook, so I tried it with this fish and let me tell you it was incredible. I try to get fish and chips everywhere I go, my favorite spot is usually Universal Studios Orlando, and this was honestly so close to that. It comes in one big bag with 12 pieces inside, so you get a good amount. My husband and I both split the bag and ate 3 pieces each and we were full, so we are getting two meals out of it. I cooked it for 9 minutes like the instructions said, but I flipped the pieces and gave them another 5 minutes, which made them perfect. The batter is light, the fish is super flaky, and it's clearly high quality. I ate it with some Publix tartar sauce and it was delicious. This is reason enough for me to keep coming back to Sam's, please keep this stocked because it's going to be a regular for me.