Customer reviews for Member's Mark Wild Caught Skinless and Boneless Beer Battered Cod Fillets, Frozen, 11-15 ct., 2 lbs. forMember's Mark Wild Caught Skinless and Boneless Beer Battered Cod Fillets, Frozen, 11-15 ct., 2 lbs.
Most helpful positive review
3 customers found this helpful
4 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Skeptical
JF52
Most helpful negative review
11 customers found this helpful
1 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Greasy, heavily breaded fillets
Doug
9,312 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
- 4 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/24/2026We have tried many frozen fish filets. The Members Mark brand was very good. Filets are kinda small but the batter was crispy and the fish was ...... FISH. Happy customer here.
Skeptical
JF52 - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/26/2025I used to love this fish. I don't know if they changed vendors for the fish. The packaging is different this time. FIRST TIME fish was really tough . I don't think I'll be getting them again.
Disappointed
Lil - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/9/2025This is really good battered cod. Enyoyed it very much. Easy to prepare taking less than one half hour to bake. My family of two is getting three nice size meals from this one box.
Delicious Fishes
NYBennie - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase9/23/2025Tastes great. Ovens vary, I have to lower by 5 degrees so it doesn’t get too dark. I place the fish on parchment paper with avocado oil sprayed over all.
Very flaky and crispy
Kris - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase9/22/2025Got these fillets to compare them with Groton’s fillets. I air fry them and they were way too greasy. They also like the brand name ones had too much breading and not enough meat. I won’t buy either of them again.
Greasy, heavily breaded fillets
Doug - 1 out of 5 stars review5/31/2026We used to LOVE this fish! It is now disgusting. My husband and I threw most of it out. It's like it was garbage in the fish. Hard, rubbery and just unappetizing. Don't know what has happened but they keep raising the price and the quality has plummeted. Skip this one for sure!
Quality has gone way down
- 2 out of 5 stars review7/5/2026We have purchased this in the past and it was amazing but we just purchased again and we had several pieces that still had the skin on and you couldn't cut through the fish. it's normally flaky and had a great taste but now I'm afraid to buy any more because of this and they are so expensive.Paula
- 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase8/31/2026We love these battered cod fillets not only for the taste but also the convenience. Perfect serving size for each filet, with the perfect ratio of batter, which isn’t too heavy. They heat up nicely in the toaster oven & we like to make filet sandwiches & fish tacos/burritos with them.
Make great sandwiches and tacos
El - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase8/1/2026The fish looked good out of the box. I followed the instructions exactly for air frying. At the end of the cook, the breading was still a little light for me so I cooked it 5 more minutes. On the outside, the crust was crispy. On the inside, it was completely raw and inedible. Members Mark is close to a really good product with this fish, but not with that breading.
Good fish ruined by the breading
Que - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase12/28/2025Beer battered fillets are good enough to use in a sandwich or as an entree. Will purchase again for sure.
Fish finder
NWISC - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase1/11/2026I love how this has no fishy taste and/or smell. I don’t have to use any kind of seasoning(s) and/or condiment(s).
Nothing Fishy Here
D Fragalé - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase9/10/2026Cut too close to the spine and meat was tough, maybe toughest fish I have encountered. Very disappointing as this has been a good product in the past. The entire bag was just not right.
Disappointing, poor cut or tough old cod.
CDS - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase9/2/2026These were not good at all…threw the rest of the box away! It had big chunks that were too hard to chew and they were very fishy tasting. The batter wasn't bad but not worth buying again. Sorry
Won't buy again
Julie - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase5/27/2026These are mostly batter and grease. I always bought the unbattered frozen cod fillets which were thick and healthy. These were very thin with unhealthy ingredients and I will not buy again. I will buy my fish now elsewhere because they stopped having the good cod.
Not Good
Abcd123 - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase7/30/2026This is actually really yummy however, they've ruined it by using canola oil, and maltodextrin. These 2 are the worst on the list of ingredients, for me anyway.
Good but..
Bria - 4 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase5/12/2026If you're looking for a solid frozen fish option, these cod fillets are a winner. They come out fantastic in the air fryer—nice and flaky on the inside without that heavy, dripping grease you sometimes get with battered seafood. Why They're Great: • Quality Texture: The fish is genuinely flaky, and the beer batter has a great crunch. • Air Fryer Friendly: They crisp up perfectly in the air fryer, keeping the meal feeling a bit lighter. • Versatile: These are our go-to for fish sandwiches. Add some tartar sauce and a bun, and they're better than a drive-thru. The Downside: • Size: The fillets are a little on the small side. If you're making a sandwich on a standard bun, you might find yourself wishing the patties were just a bit bigger to fi...
Perfect we're at home fish sandwiches
Bk - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase8/16/2025We sort of stumbled across these and were skeptical, but bought a box. Pleasantly surprised at how delicious they were and full of fish. The battered fish ratio is great and normally I’m not a fan of baking anything, I’d rather fry it, but these came out great in the oven, crispy like you fried them. We have since bought another box and they are one of our new favorite go to’s for a fast dinner!!
High quality and great price!
Bubblesbrew - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/7/2025Not too fishy and the beer batter doesnt taste too much like beer, as with other brands. Not too mushy, i bake them per the instructions and they come out perfectly crispy. Easy to burn them or overcook them though, so be careful. We make fish tacos with them. We make our own spicy fish sauce. Lemon. Cabbage. Regular corn tortillas. Delicious.
Crispy perfection
Monique - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase12/18/2024I really enjoy these Member's Mark Wild Caught cod fillets. They are so easy to prepare in the air fryer and come out perfect. I live alone and it makes a very quick and healthy meal. I find the Member's Mark products are high quality and prefer to purchase that brand.
Excellent value for quality Wild Caught Cod fillet
DakotaLady - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase7/3/2022Sams Club changed supplier again for this fish. As others have mentioned they are now not sized consistently, many pieces are very small, square shaped. Also they are thicker so do not cook the same. They also taste somewhat different now. Not bad but not as good as before. Cook 4 minutes longer than what the instructions say.
Changed
jack