I have been buying this fish for years and have absolutely loved it, up until today. The pieces are now small and most of the other reviews are spot on, they are now flavorless mush. We will never buy this fish again!

This is much better than the Cod that came in the blue box. I don't know if it is as good as the original Cod Sam's had before switching to the blue box but I will buy this one again.

They were disgusting!! A huge piece of unchewable rubbery piece of the fish filet came out with my first bite! I couldn't eat it and the other one was all mushyand slimy! What kind of fish is this anyway! 😳

I was hoping they had gone back to the original formula (old red box), but this is not it. Though, I must say it is an improvement over the stuff in the blue boxes. The batter does get nice and crispy, but the pieces are still on the small side.

I have been buying this fish for years , and I noticed it's not the same quality. Recently found small pieces of fish bone . It says boneless, but be careful

I’m not sure what happened between the previous ones I have purchased and this new batch, but there’s way too much breading. They aren’t even baking completely through, not like the old ones. I think they’re just trying to sell the weight in breading and not actual fish.

We have been buying these for a while in our local Sam's Club, but haven't been able to find them in several months. They make a great quick meal. I put them in my air fryer, then fix some sides or wrap them in a tortilla for a quick fish taco. Please, Sam's Club, make these available again in our local club.

At one time, we gave these a 5-Star review. However, the last two boxes tasted awful. They tasted overly fishy and heavily breaded. Also, guar gum is now listed as an ingredient. We only buy wild caught fish and don't mind paying for quality. Unfortunately, the quality of these has drastically plummeted. These filets now contain large, inedible, hard, discolored chunks that can not be chewed. No longer light and flaky. Our little one used to look forward to eating these and just said, "YUCK", they're "Bisgusting". Sadly, we agree. Please steer clear. We can no longer recommend these.

Cooked them in the air fryer at first and noted the bland flavor and rough texture of the fish. During cooking it seems that the fish loses a lot of moisure, but the moisture can't escape so you end up with internally dry but externally wet fish. I tried again in the oven but the results were the same. They're not bad enough to throw them in the trash, but not good enough to warrant buying. Gordon's seems way better and I'd rather have fish sticks than these.

Purchased yesterday and threw away yesterday! Why: Gummy (some portions) , Unlikable smell, Greasy, overall inedible. This is my personal experience. What hurts the most is having to through it away and wasting $12.78… Other Members Mark products are Excellent!