Last 2 boxes have been a big disappointment. Odd shapes of fish from nuggets to thick fish sticks to a few regular size fillets. Fish doesn’t heat up evenly and just isn’t good anymore. Seems there is no quality control so I won’t be purchasing again. What happened?

Apparently they get this fish from a different supplier, not even sure it's Cod anymore. The appearance alone changed quite a bit, MUCH smaller pieces and cut in strips, nothing like the picture on the box anymore. The taste was NOT good, it was like eating a piece of sponge! I know we having supply chain issues but that's NO excuse for giving people crappy food AND it had less n the box and the price has increased....of course.

While the flavor is not bad, the texture and consistency are. I received two boxes that had nubs (nugget or smaller sized) for about a quarter of a box each. The normal consistency should be at least as long as my index finger, but there were quite a number of crust only ones in the boxes.

This is the second time I ate from this box and It is as bad as the first time. One piece had the back and some guts strung thur the item. I can't call it a fillet as there was very little solid fish inside and it has no flavor. Just a lot of mush with no flavor. a little fish with a lot more mush around it and just plain gross. I have loved the beer battered fish in the past but what is in this package is not even close. There is more in the box but to gross to eat.

I bought this item about 3 weeks ago but it came in a white box. My first batch was cooked in my airfryer under the recommended time and heat settings on the box. 2nd batch was in the air fryer again in the bake/roast setting (higher temp,450) and much longer time. With both cooking methods the fish was soggy as heck, the batter was falling apart and coming off the fish and the fish was bland and tasteless. An absolute waste of money. You can also fry it in a deep fryer but I don't have one and I know it's not going to come out much different. One of the worst products I have ever gotten from Sam's Club.

This is not fit for human consumption! There are chunks of hard, bony cartilage-like substances in it, along with skin. Some parts are so mushy it looks like milk coming out when you cut it. I have never returned a food item in my life that I can recall, but I did with this stuff. Zero stars is more appropriate. Also, FWIW, the box was white, as some other reviewers have noted the change. Sam's was good and did not question the return.

I bought these as they were sampling them in March, 2022. They were really good and we had them for dinner a few times. I had forgotten about them until a few weeks ago and got them again. This time they were inconsistent sizes so they did not cook evenly. But the ones that were cooked were still very good.

Taste, which is most important, was great. Not fishy. Beer flavor was not over-powering. I had a few left over and re-heated them and they were pretty much the same taste and consistency. They were a solid piece of fish, but tender. They were easy to prepare, first time in the oven with fries and the second time in the Air Fryer. I would purchase them again.

I bought these before and they were great. The last box I bought was terrible. I just cooked 4 pieces of fish and couldn't eat 2 of them because they were very hard and chewy and tasted bad. They seemed to be cut different. The other 2 were flaky and good. Not worth the gamble to see if they are good or not.

These little cod filets are great in the air fryer. They have just the right amount of crispness without being too oily. I have only had with rice and tartar sauce, but I bet they would be good as a fish sandwich. You would need at least 2 filets to make the sandwich and they are a little smaller.