It is smooth and not chalky or grainy at all. I also like the bottle design, it’s easy to carry around or slip into a bag. The taste of the protein shake is pretty good but the chocolate flavor is a little weak.

These used to be really good, and the perfect consistency. Then they changed the recipe or something. They are so thick now. I have to switch to another brand because of the thickness.

These are excellent! They provide the perfect balance of chocolate flavor and the vitamins, minerals, and protein needed. I really enjoy the taste…to me no harsh aftertaste!

Changed formula to a watery tasteless drink. Removed sodium but also other things without notice. Fewer in box. This was 1 of two products I joined specifically to purchase so will not be renewing Sams membership!

Replaced the Red Packaged Members Mark Protein Shakes... They are now 15 pack instead of 18 pack and the price is still the same... Shame on Sam's Club for "rebranding" to make more profit.

Was drinking Premier Protein and tried this one. It is just as good as the name brand, and considerably cheaper. Several of my friends have switched over!!!

Bought these as they were out of Fairlife shakes and wish I would have skipped. Nasty in comparison. Real fake protein taste. Bad aftertaste. Stick with Fairlife!

THICK. I have to chug it. Watching it pour from its bottle to a cup is so digesting to look at. It's so hard to finish. Honestly, just get the fairlife brand it's much better.

The last box that we opened we couldn't open the lids without breaking the container open. Big mess. After getting open the foil seal was still closed. What a pain.

The chocolate flavor is good, but not rich or creamy. There is a slight after taste, which may come from the container. The container is cardbord, not a plactic bottle, like Boost. Will not buy again.